Tracker continues to deliver pulse-pounding action in “Shades of Gray,” a gripping, fast-paced episode filled with crime, deception, and Colter once again finding himself in way over his head. What starts as a simple missing person case quickly morphs into a full-blown criminal conspiracy, forcing Colter to navigate dangerous power players and family betrayals—all while dodging bullets and outsmarting mobsters.
Opening Chaos: Colter’s in Trouble—Again
One of Tracker’s strengths is its ability to throw us right into the action, and this episode wastes no time. The episode kicks off with Colter in a rough spot, held at gunpoint and getting roughed up by two thugs. They warn him about sticking his nose where it doesn’t belong, but if we know anything about Colter, it’s that he never takes good advice. Who are these guys? Why are they after him? This quick, jarring start keeps the audience on edge before we even know what case Colter is taking on.
Meanwhile, Reenie is working late when her boyfriend, Elliott, interrupts her with flowers and a reminder about their forgotten date night. It’s a sweet moment—until Elliott’s phone rings with a new client, forcing him to rush out of town. Something feels off, and Reenie immediately calls Colter. The case? A young man named Matt Hale has vanished without a trace, and his mother, Ivy, is desperate to find him.
A Missing Son & A Mother With Secrets
A Missing Son & A Mother With Secrets
At first, Matt Hale’s disappearance seems like a typical case for Colter—a young man vanishes, and his worried mother hires Colter to track him down. But Tracker takes the story in an unexpected direction, weaving in deception, hidden agendas, and a criminal empire lurking beneath the surface.
Colter heads to New Jersey to meet Ivy at her bakery chain, where he learns that Matt is a Columbia-educated analyst who disappeared two days ago, leaving behind his car and phone. While Ivy appears to be a concerned mother, there are subtle red flags—her cousin, Casey, seems indifferent about Matt’s disappearance, and there’s tension surrounding Matt’s personal life, particularly his relationship with a married woman.
 |
| “Shades of Gray” – TRACKER, Pictured: Justin Hartley as Colter Shaw and Amy Pietz as Ivy Hale. Photo: Darko Sikman/CBS ©2025 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved. |
As Colter digs deeper, he tracks down Matt’s girlfriend, Lucy, only to find her tied up in her art studio. She reveals that Matt was abducted by two people with Eastern European accents who confirmed his identity before taking him. This wasn’t random—someone specifically wanted Matt.
Colter Walks Into the Lion’s Den
Following Matt’s last known whereabouts, Colter ends up at a shady hotel, where he stumbles upon an underground crime operation. That’s where he meets Rick Lindo, a rival businessman who drops a bombshell—Ivy isn’t just a bakery owner, she’s a major player in New Jersey’s criminal underworld, with powerful connections and politicians in her pocket.
This revelation turns everything Colter thought he knew about the case upside down. Ivy’s desperation to find Matt suddenly carries new weight—is she truly worried about her son, or is she more concerned about protecting her empire?
Rick, seeing an opportunity to take Ivy down for good, orders his men to kill Colter. But Colter, ever resourceful, manages to talk his way out of execution. One of Rick’s men—who turns out to be a childhood friend of Matt’s—secretly lets Colter go, revealing a crucial piece of the puzzle: Matt was set up. Someone wanted him to be seen with the Lindos, stirring up conflict between the two rival factions.
The question now isn’t just where is Matt?—it’s who is pulling the strings, and why?
The Mastermind Revealed
This revelation turns everything Colter thought he knew about the case upside down. Ivy’s desperation to find Matt suddenly carries new weight—is she truly worried about her son, or is she more concerned about protecting her empire?
Rick, seeing an opportunity to take Ivy down for good, orders his men to kill Colter. But Colter, ever resourceful, manages to talk his way out of execution. One of Rick’s men—who turns out to be a childhood friend of Matt’s—secretly lets Colter go, revealing a crucial piece of the puzzle: Matt was set up. Someone wanted him to be seen with the Lindos, stirring up conflict between the two rival factions.
The question now isn’t just where is Matt?—it’s who is pulling the strings, and why?
The Mastermind Revealed
As tensions mount, Ivy receives a chilling message—a photo of Matt’s extracted tooth. Convinced the Lindos have her son, she prepares for a confrontation, ignoring Colter’s warnings that she’s walking into a trap. The real mastermind? Casey, Ivy’s own cousin.
The episode cleverly planted Casey as a red herring before revealing he’s actually the mastermind behind Matt’s kidnapping. While his motivations make sense—jealousy, resentment, and the desire for power—his downfall feels a bit rushed. He goes from playing it cool to full-on villain monologue mode in record time, and his death-by-electrocution, while dramatic, feels a little convenient.
Meanwhile, Matt’s old friend, the same man who spared Colter’s life, rescues Matt from his warehouse prison just in time.
The episode cleverly planted Casey as a red herring before revealing he’s actually the mastermind behind Matt’s kidnapping. While his motivations make sense—jealousy, resentment, and the desire for power—his downfall feels a bit rushed. He goes from playing it cool to full-on villain monologue mode in record time, and his death-by-electrocution, while dramatic, feels a little convenient.
Meanwhile, Matt’s old friend, the same man who spared Colter’s life, rescues Matt from his warehouse prison just in time.
 |
| “Shades of Gray” – TRACKER, Pictured: Justin Hartley as Colter Shaw and J.J. Soria as Vargas. Photo: Sergei Bachlakov/CBS ©2025 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved. |
The Aftermath: A Debt to Colter & Dirty Money
With Matt safe, Ivy faces a reckoning. Colter asks if she’ll finally leave her criminal life behind, but Ivy dodges the question, instead offering him a favor in return. Colter declines, knowing her kind of help comes with strings.
At his resting place by the water overlooking the New York skyline, Colter winds down with a beer by the fire when Reenie stops by, delivering his $50,000 reward. But Colter, recognizing it as dirty money, decides to donate it to charity. Their easy banter ends the episode on a lighter note, though Colter makes it clear—he still doesn’t trust Elliott.
Colter and Reenie’s dynamic continues to be one of the show’s most intriguing slow burns. There’s an undeniable connection between them—mutual respect, trust, and a natural ease that suggests something deeper simmering beneath the surface. But while the tension is palpable, their vastly different lives keep them from ever fully acknowledging it. Colter thrives on simplicity and independence, a man constantly on the move, unburdened by attachments. Reenie, on the other hand, is firmly rooted in the structured world of law and high-profile clients, balancing ambition with stability. Their opposing worlds create an unspoken barrier, yet every lingering glance, shared joke, and moment of concern hints at what they refuse to admit—there’s something there, something real, but neither is willing to cross the line.
Final Thoughts: A Thrilling Web of Crime & Betrayal
At his resting place by the water overlooking the New York skyline, Colter winds down with a beer by the fire when Reenie stops by, delivering his $50,000 reward. But Colter, recognizing it as dirty money, decides to donate it to charity. Their easy banter ends the episode on a lighter note, though Colter makes it clear—he still doesn’t trust Elliott.
Colter and Reenie’s dynamic continues to be one of the show’s most intriguing slow burns. There’s an undeniable connection between them—mutual respect, trust, and a natural ease that suggests something deeper simmering beneath the surface. But while the tension is palpable, their vastly different lives keep them from ever fully acknowledging it. Colter thrives on simplicity and independence, a man constantly on the move, unburdened by attachments. Reenie, on the other hand, is firmly rooted in the structured world of law and high-profile clients, balancing ambition with stability. Their opposing worlds create an unspoken barrier, yet every lingering glance, shared joke, and moment of concern hints at what they refuse to admit—there’s something there, something real, but neither is willing to cross the line.
Final Thoughts: A Thrilling Web of Crime & Betrayal
“Shades of Gray” delivers exactly what Tracker does best—high-stakes action, morally complex characters, and a case that keeps twisting until the very end. “Shades of Gray” is no exception, offering an intricate case with twists, betrayals, and morally complex players. But while the show excels at keeping Colter on the move, solving other people’s problems, it rarely slows down to explore his own. We get glimpses—his preference for solitude, his reluctance to trust—but when will the show start peeling back his own layers? Colter is an enigma, shaped by past trauma that we’ve only scratched the surface of. As thrilling as each case is, diving deeper into what drives him could add even more emotional weight to the series, making the stakes feel just as personal for Colter as they do for the people he helps.
