Stalker - Love Hurts - Review: "We have a serial killer"
16 May 2015
DV Reviews StalkerStalker's penultimate episode focussed on a murder and an attempted murder, but as the hour drew to a close, it became clear that both cases were far from solved.
The episode begins with a woman named Francine Johnson being stabbed to death. Francine was stalked by her boyfriend John, who got out of prison a few weeks ago. However, since he was in another state, he couldn't be the killer. Meanwhile, Janice has another case. A woman named Pam suspects her ex-husband Darren violated the restraining order by leaving gifts and stalking her. Later that night, Pam walks to her house, but is confronted by another man. He says he ruined her life and attacks her, but Pam manages to make it to her house. The man who attacked her was not her ex-husband, but her former co-worker Clay, who was fired last month for sexual harassment. Clay says he just wanted to talk to her, but he didn't mean to attack her. Also, Darren's car was spotted in the area, but Darren claims he is over Pam. He knows things didn't end well and has now joined a love and sex addiction support group. However, Pam is once again attacked in her house, and this time she is almost stabbed with her letter opener.
Both Clay and Darren have an alibi for the night. Darren was at a dinner with some people from the support group, who confirm his alibi. However, they also say that Darren has had a rough time because his wife cheated on him. Pam denies ever having cheated and she only said so, because she was upset about Darren's cheating. The case becomes even weirder when Clay is attacked while jogging and is left for dead. As Jack and Janice look at surveillance footage, they see Darren's car parked nearby. They head to his apartment and find a wall full of photos from Pam. Jack also finds medication for bipolar disorder and wonders if he's in a manic state. Meanwhile, Pam is doing volunteer work at a church, but hears some strange noises. She heads inside and sees the priest lying on the ground. Darren reveals he didn't mean to hurt him. He admits to sending her the gifts and just wanted to see her. He also hurt himself, but Pam manages to run away. With Jack and Janice arriving, Darren is arrested and Pam says she never knew he was sick.
However, something bothers Janice about the case and she has another look at the files. She later calls Vicky with her findings. When Pam was nearly killed with her letter opener, both Darren and Clay had an alibi. Pam also said Darren would never hurt her, so it must have been someone else. The case reminds Janice of the Francine Johnson murder, which had the same MO. She found an additional four murders with the same MO and says all stalkers attended a love and sex addiction support group. Vicky realizes they have a serial killer on the loose.
Elsewhere, Beth is not back at work yet and is not sure if she wants to. After all, she was Beth Davis but now everyone knows she is Michelle Webber. In the meantime, she keeps herself busy with two things. First of all, she flirts with Jack and Jack flirts back. Eventually, this leads to a heart-to-heart conversation between the two, in which Beth reveals she doesn't know what to do next. Jack says he hopes he's a part of her next chapter and the two of them kiss.
Also, per Vicky's request, Beth looks into an old case in which a man, Stan Gardner, was convicted for killing his wife. He always denied the murder and said he had an alibi, and after so many years, his alibi comes forward and corroborates it. Beth later confirms that she doesn't think Stan is the killer. She tells Vicky to have a new look at the case and start with her ex-husband Will. Will showed up at Vicky's office earlier in the hour to invite her for some drinks and finalize their divorce. Vicky knows Will slept with the victim and she gave him an alibi at the time. However, Vicky reveals that she and Will had a fight and the latter slept in the guest room. Vicky didn't see him until the next morning. She later has drinks with Will and asks if he's heard about Stan Gardner. She says she screwed up if Stan truly didn't kill his wife.
Obviously this story is far from over and will continue in Monday's series finale. This episode did a good job of setting it all up, although given that I already read the press release, it wasn't much of a surprise that a serial killer was involved. The stalking case of Pam was an interesting one, though I think she was really unlucky. After all, she was attacked three times this episode by three different people. We have seen two stalkers on this show before, but I think having three stalkers is a record. It will be interesting to see who the serial killer is in the next episode. I am currently suspecting the leader of the support group and Vicky's ex-husband Will. There must be a reason why Will suddenly shows up in Vicky's life. I'm glad he's not stalking her, because that would be too obvious. Making him a suspected murderer instead is quiet interesting.
My main criticism of this episode is Jack and Beth. I never wanted them to get romantically involved and I am still against that. Additionally, their flirting and eventual kiss felt so incredibly forced. They have never flirted before, so to suddenly see them flirting came out of nowhere. Yes, Jack might have protected Beth from Ray and saved her from him, but that still doesn't explain the fact that they suddenly care for one another. If we had gotten some more build-up to their kiss, I could have accepted it a bit better.
Lastly, I'm not ashamed to say that I didn't miss Ben in this episode. His character has been so underused this season that I don't care much about him. If Stalker had gotten a season 2, I wouldn't have minded Vicky being promoted to series regular.
What did you think about "Love Hurts"? How do you think the serial arc will continue on the next episode? Do you think that Will might be up to something? Who do you think the serial killer is? And lastly, how do you feel about the kiss between Jack and Beth? I would love to hear your comments in the comment section below.
Stalker airs its series finale this Monday at 9/8c on CBS. I hope it doesn't end in a cliffhanger. Here's a promo of the episode:
Sign Up for the SpoilerTV Newsletter where we talk all things TV!
I'm with you!! I really hope they don't end with a cliffhanger. That'd be awful!!! Ben, compared to the other team members, felt almost useless. There were very few moments where it felt like Ben had a noticeable impact on the cases. The real problem was that if Ben had died, I don't think it would have made a huge impact on the show. I wish this show wasn't getting cancelled. It was CBS's best show of the year.
ReplyDeleteYou're so on point with the out-of-nowhere flirting between Jack and Beth. She never really liked him before and even though her long-time stalker is gone, now she's a loose , flirty teenager? I thought she was a tough, Lieutenant? Thanks for your review. Agree on all counts.
ReplyDeleteActually we've seen moments between Jack and Beth that show MORE than friendship, it started when jack first learned about Ray, the movie night is among the bigger moments between them. Yeah i am DREADING if i should watch next week, i don't want to risk being left hanging, Williamson isn't exactly known for closed season finales. I mean how many shows that got the "C" word ended on a resolution, i can barely count them on my hands. The only ones i can think of are: Leverage, WOW! see, basically only one LOL, although supposedly The Messengers will have a satisfying ending.
ReplyDeleteThis was a solid episode and a solid series, they got this one wrong, it deserves an s2. True, the kiss seamed a little rushed but not totally out of the blue they've had a few moments throughout the season. And let's face it, it was obvious they've been pushing a romance between them, now is there only chance, they had no choice but to rush it.
ReplyDeleteI agree on this review so much! Glad many people see how forced and non believable this Jack and Beth kind-of-romance now. Even if someone still think there was 'moments' between them doesn't change the fact of how those 'moments' was forced. Even him protecting/saving her life thing was totally forced. Whole story never was developed properly. We have never seen a really emotional moments between them and here's either, writing failure or lack of chemistry between the actors, but that's it. Plus feels like people who accepting this storyline, doing that just because they comparing to some other cop shows while ignoring whole fact that Stalker stll completely different. In addition want to remind that Jack used to stalk his ex and his son just like many other stalkers, but the writers and some people seems like forgetting that. Yes he didn't hurt them physically or mentally but there's still fact: HE HAS STALKER TENDENCIES. Involving him romantically with Beth just disgusting, considering the show's concept and all stories we have watched through the season.
ReplyDeleteYeah, it wouldn't have been a big loss to me if Ben had died. He was pretty useless throughout the season. I too wish this show wasn't getting cancelled, but now all I hope for is it doesn't end with a cliffhanger.
ReplyDeleteThanks! It really came out of nowhere. At the beginning of the season, she seemd to hate Jack but now she suddenly appears to be in love with him. I get that she needs to redefine who she is now that everyone knows she is Michelle, but turning to Jack is not the solution.
ReplyDeleteThere have been little moments here and there, but they also felt forced. I understand Jack is worried for Beth's safety but that doesn't mean he needs to hook up with her. I still think they are forcing Jack and Beth as a couple.
ReplyDeleteI am looking forward to the finale but also fearing it will end on a cliffhanger. Like you say, Williamson isn't known for cliffhanger-free finales. The recent interview with TVLine after the spring premiere seems to indicate that he is well aware of the low ratings, so I hope he realizes it'd be best to not end with a cliffhanger. He also said he pushed the intended cliffhanger to the winter finale so hopefully he won't do one again for the finale.
I agree, I would have liked a season 2. I still don't understand why all the critics panned this show before it premiered, because it was far from bad.
ReplyDeleteI don't need a romance between Jack and Beth at all. I think they're pushing it because of Maggie and Dylan's engagement. But it feels so unnatural to pair them on-screen.
But admit those 'moments' was just like moments between Beth and Ben or between Beth and Ben. If we start comparing, they equivalently could put Beth with any team member then. And even if they planned it, they have choice. Nothing written on the stone. If things being pushed this is just bad television
ReplyDeleteYeah i read that but was him knowing about the ratings before or AFTER he got the news?
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely agree on your comment. This really highlights why I don't agree with this romance. It feels so forced on all sides. Beth seemed to hate Jack when he first came in and while that has cooled off, they are now taking it way too far by hooking them up. I mean, from Beth's point of view, you go from hating someone to loving that same person within a year. I am glad they dropped Jack's stalking at the beginning, but Beth knows what he did. She shouldn't forget that.
ReplyDeleteYou know what confuses me, this show is like BORN to be CBS, i HATE this term for a show "procedural" but it just fits they have Criminal Minds, the NCIS's and the CSI's why could they have had this as well?
ReplyDeleteIt was this interview: http://tvline.com/2015/04/27/stalker-ray-dead-season-1-spoilers-cbs/
ReplyDeleteHe said he had already been laying a groundwork for season 2, but also said he remained cautiously optimistic on getting a renewal. That seems to indicate that he is at least aware the ratings aren't what they should be. He also talks about moving up the cliffhanger and other stuff.
Oh, and I'm not sure if you still think Ray is alive and while Williamson does not confirm his death, the interview strongly suggests Ray is gone. Just saying ;)
Ok and well he's dead NOW after the news obviously LOL
ReplyDeleteWell, of course it has nearly everything to do with the ratings. It had the most compatible lead-in it could wish for (Criminal Minds), but still it premiered to just a 2.0 demo and slowly fell apart after that. I was and still am disappointed with its low ratings. Also take in mind that Stalker is the only freshman drama premiered in fall that is from an outside studio (i.e. it is now owned by CBS itself).
ReplyDeleteBy the way, CBS renewed three freshman dramas in January (Madam Secretary, Scorpion and NCIS: New Orleans) and neither of them ended on a cliffhanger even though they all had a very early renewal. I will be really pissed if the only cancelled drama (Battle Creek aside) does end on a cliffhanger.
i agree on both comments! i'm not happy about the fact that they dropped jack's stalking because this is leaving hole in this story and seems very hypocritical to drop or excuse it just because he is a lead. the romance between him and beth are wrong at all the points. also, i dont' think beth knows about stalking. he obviously told her about his past with amanda and about ethan but i don't think she knows part of the story when he was peeing through amanda's windows. if she knew he has this tendence for stalking, she wouldn't flirt with him.
ReplyDeleteIt always comes back to ratings doesn't it? I wish ratings didn't matter in the renewal decisions, that they look at fans reactions and stuff. But at the end of the day it's a business isn't it?
ReplyDeletejust in addition to the part about beth and jack, i don't see them as a couple at all. i think because actors got surprising lack of chemistry on screen. i don't see connection between them, they absolutely different people with different personalities, different pasts, etc. jack saved her life arc just forced as hell and still didn't give a reason why they should be together. i haven't seen anything special in it and just because one coworker helping another doesn't mean beth owe jack herself. nothing romantic in such writing.
ReplyDeleteand like someone pointed out, jack appeared as stalker and for me nothing can remove this creepy picture of him out of my mind. stalking, even when this is still harmless, it is still stalking. beside that, jack is very arrogant, far from honest, etc and being like that his whole life, he couldn't change in a couple of months. this whole beth/jack storyline makes me cringe because it's like if you white adult men you can do what you want, getting away with it but the story tells people root for 'hero' like that. while there's a woman who falls in trust for him and falls in love, she is doomed to suffer but it all being romanticized. this is just FSOG idea all over again and it should be stopped or should stay on FSOG!
Apparently they got some chemistry off-screen since the actors are engaged, but I just don't see them as a couple. For all the reasons you mentioned, they don't need to get romantically involved.
ReplyDeleteGreat Review! I'm already excited for the next episode although i might know who the serial killer is. I guess it's the tall,brown haired guy from the support group. The one who talked to the woman that gave the crazy ex husband an alibi.
ReplyDelete