Outlander - The Search - Review: "Love Forces a Person to Choose"
May 10, 2015
Outlander Reviews RFOutlander - The Search - Review
Last week on Outlander, The Watch and Horrocks arrived at Lallybroch. Ian killed Horrocks after Jamie was being blackmailed by him for money, Jenny went into labor and gave birth to a girl, and Claire confessed to Jamie that she might not be able to have children. Also, Jamie, after agreeing to accompany The Watch on their latest raid, due to them being a man short, got ambushed, and most of The Watch were slaughtered with Ian escaping and Jamie captured by the redcoats.
"Love forces a person to choose" Jenny
Claire, this episode, decides to pursue Jamie, even though looking for him, yet alone finding him, is near to impossible. Nevertheless Claire, with a stubborn Jenny, who refused to let Claire go alone, left Lallybroch to try to locate their beloved Jamie.
They had to start their search somewhere and started it at the place where he and The Watch were ambushed. This was a chilling scene. Watching the crows pick away at the bodies, the eyes, in particular, was disgusting, but it really showed the importance of burning or burying dead bodies. Even if the men who died were pigs, which they were, nobody deserves to get eaten away at. Jenny saying a small prayer for the deceased was a nice touch and it really showed her character in a different light, someone who cares not just her family, but all, like Claire.
It's been clear ever since we first met Jenny that she cares deeply for Jamie, but this episode proved how far she is willing to go for the sake of her brother. When Claire and Jenny stumble across a camp and both capture a courier, Jenny decides to torture him. Having Jenny torture that man though sent a powerful message, that there is nothing stronger than a sibling bond. Jenny proved that. She isn't afraid to do things that are considered violent and inhumane, which is why I'm loving Jenny as a character, she's strong and does what needs to be done for the sake of her family, she does what most people are afraid to do; fight for her family by any means necessary; you can't condemn her for that.
Claire showed some character herself this episode in the scene that followed the couriers torture. Claire's strong, but not physically,more intellectually, so it surprised me when she showed great courage in claiming she would have, if Murtagh didn't, killed the courier. She's not a killer, but even Claire is learning that in some situations there isn't a choice. This is what makes Claire's development as a character even more appealing. She's started off as a lost English woman trapped in a different time, now she's learning to adapt to new situations even if she's not too fond of them. She's learning to make choices with her heart and not her head, which isn't wrong, doing so shows great character and courage.
"Go home to Lallybroch" Murtagh
Murtagh returned this episode and played a key part in helping Claire locate Jamie. Murtagh's always seen Jamie as a friend, but he sees him as more than that, he sees him as the son he never had. Murtagh is one of few emotions, but this episode he really opened up to Claire, and I felt that we got to know him a bit better, the real him, the reasons why he thinks highly of Jamie and why he would jump at the chance to help him. Murtagh is attached to Jamie, he couldn't save the woman he loved, but can save the son he wishes he had, helping Claire rescue Jamie is something he needs to do.
It was a heart-breaking moment hearing Murtagh tell Claire about the love he lost. I was devastated for him, and even shed a tear. It's never easy watching a character breakdown but watching a character who is not only tough, but someone who hides their emotions break down, made the scene much harder to take in. It goes to show that even the toughest of men are emotionally attached to something. Duncan Lacroix in that scene, in particular, was superb. He's another actor like Steven who won't get too many moments to shine, and really take the spotlight away from Caitronia and Sam, but he did this episode, and he deserves some attention for that.
Murtagh and Claire was an unexpected pairing, but it worked so well throughout the episode. There wasn't too much chemistry between them, but gradually as the episode progressed they bonded. Most of their time spent together included lots of laugh out loud moments, but when the show touched upon the more personal and heart to heart moments it really made the pairing even more perfect, so much so that I didn't want their scenes to end. The pairing also showed how well rounded the cast is, to be able to still deliver high quality scenes and episodes without their leading man.
What really caught my eye though was Claire's singing. Claire wasn't too keen on Murtagh’s idea, but once she started it brought out a whole different side of her. Ever since arriving she hasn't been able to do something that she liked doing, sure she was doing it for Jamie, but she managed to get a lot of enjoyment from it, which also happened to build her confidence back up, which was later used in her argument with Dougal, which was needed.
Speaking of Dougal, he returned this episode and was more despicable than ever. Dougal is a man without honor, without loyalty, without respect, so nothing he said this episode came as a surprise, but the level of betrayal towards Jamie was outrageous. Dougal has his own agenda, he always has and always will, but more notably he wanted Lallybroch or at least he previously did and helping Jamie all these years, taking him under clan McKenzie was all a part of his agenda in trying to obtain it. He may not have said it was true, but the look he gave after Claire called him out on it, all but confirmed it.
What was more shocking though was how quickly Dougal gave up on Jamie. He had little, to none, hope that he was alive and instead wasted no time in offering his hand in marriage to Claire, saying he'll protect her and keep her safe. Whilst he has the ability to that and I'm sure he would, and that what he was saying was true about her needing to re-marry because she’s an English widow with nowhere to go, he wasn't really thinking of her, but himself. He's a cunning man and thinks he's smarter than he looks, but he's not. He will never gain power and the control that he wants, even if he thinks he will. Jamie isn't stupid and would have figured out what Dougal was up to all these years eventually.
Claire in the end was forced to agree to marry Dougal if Jamie turned out to be dead, because she needed men, especially after Dougal revealed where Jamie was and what was about to happen to him. She again, puts Jamie above herself, which again shows how strong their relationship is, especially when you include the fact that they’ve only been married a small while. Dougal had given up hope even before Claire arrived, but Claire hadn't. She won't stop until she finds Jamie, dead or alive, hopefully alive. I was also shocked how little Dougal thought of Jamie to not go with Claire to Wentworth, he truly is a spineless coward, and to think Jamie would go after him if he were captured.
Summary
It was a fantastic episode, and surprisingly among my favorites. It was the journey of Claire's, not the action, which really made it an enjoyable hour for me. Seeing Claire ride with different companions just showed her dedication to finding Jamie. I should add that the music throughout the hour was sensational, the best so far, I applaud Bear McCreary for his fine musical direction on the show. Also, as this episode was heavily focused on Claire, I imagine the next one will be heavily focused on Jamie. I have read the books, well some of them, and Wentworth Prison is going to be one brutal episode, I'll leave it at that. Overall, this was an exciting episode, which offered so much more than the usual episode.
As always, thank you for reading! Let me know in the comments what you thought of "The Search"
What did you think of the episode?
ReplyDeleteClaire and Jenny are badass, I miss Jamie. thanks for the review
ReplyDeleteI did as well, but I think the episode was as good as an episode without him in. Jenny especially is more badass than the lead from Die-hard. (Forget his name)
ReplyDeleteMurtagh was one of the reasons I loved the episode a lot, he's my third favorite character behind Claire and Jamie, so I was so pleased that he was featured throughout. His and Claire scenes were fantastic, I loved all of them.
I agree Murtagh is funny, can't wait for the next episode
ReplyDeleteRobert, I think you give the best reviews, your a devoted fan of the show & it show's. You've nailed everything in this review. Murtagh did shine, it was a nice side to see of him. Claire & his embrace made me tear too! Claire & Jenny finally bonding, Claire so trusting of everyone, even the Gypsies. Uncle Dougal what a dog! Looking forward to next week, maybe.
ReplyDeleteThank you Tammy! I am a devoted fan, I love everything about the show.
ReplyDeleteMurtagh was amazing this episode, he proved that he's not just a man who hides away his emotions and that he does have feelings. I'm glad he was able to let it all out, and tell Claire about the woman he loved and lost, it really made me feel for the character.
Claire can be too naive, not everyone she meets will be honorable and I think that got shown this episode with the gypsies continuing to copy her song. Although, I suppose that's what makes her such a great character she trusts people, and has faith in people to do the right thing, I wouldn't change that.
Great review, I agree about everything. Most of all about Dougal. I'm even more mad at him than I was while reading the book... he disgusted me.
ReplyDeleteThank you, and I'm glad you agreed. I also was even more mad watching his level of betrayal towards Jamie than reading it. He only cares for himself, which really angers me because Jamie would help him if he were in trouble.
ReplyDeleteHe is despicable, talking about Jamie in the past tense all the time made me furious like Claire was. I like what you said about Claire agreeing with him at the end, initially it took me by surprise to see her agreeing, but she was definitely doing it to get the chance to ask the men to join her rescue mission.
ReplyDeleteThat scene wasn't in the books from my knowledge (Him asking her to marry him), but I didn't mind the change as it made Dougal's agenda more obvious.
ReplyDeleteIf she hadn't of agreed to it she wouldn't have got the chance to ask the men, who she needed. In a way it was sort of blackmail, him making her agree to marry him or she wouldn't get any men, he's really cruel, and must think so little of Jamie.
Just got to see the "Search" episode a day late--and totally agree at how satisfying it was.
ReplyDeleteThis series keeps evolving: sometimes action, sometimes romance, sometimes politics, sometimes character development. Outlander is a prime example of why people are saying we're in a Golden Age of Television--there are no films being created that can accomplish all that Outlander has done.
Moving on, I totally agree with the other posts: excellent review, Robert! A show as good as Outlander deserves to have intelligent reviews/interpretations/appreciation. It's like literature: critical writings add to the appreciation. So, again, Kudos Robert on the review.
Regarding "Search": the major impression I'm left with is the strength of Claire. God, this woman is a force of nature, and her loyalty to Jamie is the stuff that Great Romances are made of. I loved seeing her search the countryside looking for Jamie--first bargaining with, then standing up to, the Gypsies. Which was nothing compared to seeing her stand up to Dougal. Speaking of whom...
Yes, he's a snake-in-the-grass, but I sense he's very true to the times. He didn't get to be the Clan War Lord--and live so long--without being manipulative, untrustworthy, and opportunistic. He's also the total chauvinist, and even at his age wants a young, attractive woman to warm his bed. I'm sure he believes it's his "right" to have Claire. And I see his not going to rescue Jamie as simply Dougal moving forward his personal agenda to obtain Claire. BTW, although I haven't read the books (and don't want to until after I've seen the Starz series has run its course) I think Claire is going to regret her deal with Dougal; to marry him if Jamie is dead. Given the poor communications system in 1700s Scotland, there's plenty of opportunities for inaccurate information.
One last thing about Dougal: English historical novels and dramas traditionally validate English History--the Winners (and their supporters) are the "good guys" whereas those who rebelled against the eventual winners, are often portrayed as deceitful, murderous, and immoral. [Currently, there's lots of discussion about if Richard III was the evildoer he's portrayed to be by Shakespeare and nearly all English history books.] Thus, having Dougal, who is a supporter of the failed Scottish Rebellion as an immoral character is in keeping with this tradition.
Lastly--and I may have to make this a staple of my comments every week--I have to once again comment on the beauty of Caitriona Balfe's hair. The luster of her curly locks perfectly compliments the beauty of the Scottish countryside, and in this episode, the coastline. Major props to the hair crew.
"Outlander is a prime example of why people are saying we're in a Golden Age of Television--there are no films being created that can accomplish all that Outlander has done."
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with what you said there, no film has come close in comparison to the show. It will never be replicated and nothing will ever be as good in quality as Outlander has been. TV shows now are becoming better than movies, the quality is so much higher, and there's more time to explore the relationships of characters and you can tell a more detailed and powerful story, like Outlander has.
Claire's development over the course of the season has been fantastic, she's afraid to pick a fight, and to stand up for what she believes in, what was shown this episode with both Dougal and the gypsies. Her and Jamie haven't been together long, but yet it feels like they've been married forever, that's how strong their relationship is, the story of Jamie and Claire, I think can be classed as one of the greatest romances ever.
As for Dougal, my main problem I had with him was how quickly he gave up on Jamie, so who he looked after growing up and took under his clan. Yes, he's a master of manipulation, but he hasn't once shown loyalty to anyone, he's like the Peter Baelish (game of thrones) of Outlander, slowly working his way into power. He could have show a hint of loyalty, by at least ordering his men to go with Claire, but he didn't.
Dougal wanting to marry her was in the book, IIRC, but the part of Claire agreeing to it if Jamie was dead, it wasn't.
ReplyDeleteShe agreed just to have the men to help her, knowing that she could go back to the stones and never have to marry him. She just let him think so. I'm sure Claire wouldn't leave Lallybroch to him.
He is very afraid of Jamie being better than him in any way.
I was disappointed in Rupert and Angus, that they didn't want to save Jamie. Willie was very brave!
Ah right, that was it, I knew it was something involving him wanting to marry her. I never did have the best memory ;)
ReplyDeleteI don't think she would ever willingly give Dougal what he wanted under any circumstances,she's not that type of person to give into someone who's blackmailing her in a way.
That bothered me how Rupert and Angus didn't want to save Jamie, but they were never too close, not like Murtagh-Jamie close.
Great review, Robert, thank you so much! Sorry I'm so late with my comment, I saw your pinned post on Twitter just now (been busy all week).
ReplyDeleteYou said a lot of things where all I could do was nod in agreement. I, like you, cried in the scene where Murtagh opens up to Claire. It was so heart-breaking.
I did like Cait/Claire's singing. I think she was adorable. And Murtagh's desparate attempts at dancing were so cute and funny.
Jenny, wow, she has balls, doesn't she? So small and dainty, but such a strong character!
I was more with Claire in the scene where Jenny tortures the courier, but I understood why she did it, why she had to do it. I'd do anything for my loved ones as well, so... who knows, I might react the same way in her situation. I was somewhat glad that Murtagh found them and did what he did.
Dougal, well... he's a pig. Enough said. ;)
I can't wait, although I dread it, to see episode 115.
It's always a great joy to write about such a wonderful show.
ReplyDeleteI never cry or tear up, but some scenes in Outlander just really get me. Murtagh, of all people, opening up like that was just heartbreaking. That scene was my favorite from the episode, I just loved it.
I didn't know Cait could sing, it surprised me a bit. After the episode I actually went onto youtube and instantly replayed it. I could listen to it all day.
Jenny is a true force of nature. She is strong and isn't afraid to pick a fight and stand up for what she believes in, which is what, I think, makes her such a strong and likable character. I agreed with Claire, she didn't have to do it, but if she didn't he wouldn't have talked. Jenny wanted Jamie back, and I truly think she would have done anything if it meant getting a bit closer to Jamie.