After a week away from the serialised plots of the show, ‘Q & A’ took Person of Interest back to its newfound general formula of balancing a number of the week and a Samaritan-related story. Personally, I’m a big fan of these episodes because it allows the show to have multiple things going on, while at the same time developing their stories well. Also, when haters of the show complain about the show not being about saving people any more, I can use that fact to prove them wrong.
Anyway, into the actual episode. This was another solid outing of the show. That being said, I’d probably rank this as the weakest of the episodes we’ve seen so far in 2015. ‘Q & A’ didn’t quite live up to the quality that we’ve seen from the four episodes since Christmas, despite it being a typically good episode.Claire was back in this episode, and seemingly desperate for help. At no point throughout the episode did I ever consider that she was actually there to help Finch; I was certain from the get-go that she was there as a Samaritan agent. Sure enough, that’s what happened. Person of Interest often uses a bait-and-switch - so much so that I’ve gotten to the point whereby I’m never usually that shocked when things aren’t what they appeared.
That said, I felt they made it far too obvious that Claire was still Samaritan, and I think the show would have benefitted had she actually been truthful. Quinn Shepard’s acting was fine, but Claire’s really wasn’t. The way she tried to push Finch into looking at the flash drive made it abundantly obvious that she was working for Samaritan still.
The predictability of that development hurt the plot, I feel. However, I did enjoy watching the interactions between Finch and Claire. It was nice to see Finch be able to speak about Samaritan with someone other than Team Machine; it gave the arc a nice breath of fresh air that I think worked well. And, as much as I knew the reveal was coming, it was a great moment when Claire slipped and said “Harold”. Also, Finch’s expression when she said his name was one of sadness and crushed hope, and Michael Emerson expressed it really well.
Once Claire’s secret was revealed, it allowed the episode to give us some insight into the thoughts of a newly recruited Samaritan operative and it was very interesting. “Samaritan’s not trying to subjugate humans, Harold. It’s trying to save them.” That’s along the same lines of things we’ve heard before, but it was intriguing to see that it seems to be taught as Samaritan 101. Claire clearly doesn’t understand the lengths by which Samaritan will go to ‘save humans’. Her belief that Samaritan will eliminate food and water shortages is again, something we’ve heard before (it will do so - but by killing those who are desperate), but it was bordering on saddening to watch as an intelligent young girl was unaware of the evil that her ‘employer’ was doing.
Worst of all, she thought that Harold would actually join them. “The world out there needs saving” is what she told him. She really has been tricked by Samaritan. However, there was some hope when she returned to Samaritan. Greer effectively told her that they don’t really give a damn if she died, because it’s “all for a good cause” (aka - they can just recruit more operatives). This left it quite open to the idea of Claire switching sides for real at some point, which I’d quite like to see. The other story this week saw Reese posing as security at a search company called Fetch and Retrieve, whom employed the latest number. Reese’s undercover identity allowed for some humorous moments (“Welcome to Nerd Nirvana” and his “I don’t care who took whose copy of Full Metal Hellcat 4” speech) as per usual, but the story as a whole was compelling and I enjoyed it. The fact that Anna was an MMA fighter provided a nice extra element to her character.
Person of Interest has a knack for making technology into something that really can send chills down viewers’ spines. This was another example of that, as the search software advised one user to commit suicide when he wanted help for his depression. Turned out that Fetch and Retrieve’s Chief Technical Officer Calvin put in some code to have things like that happen on occasion to push those users into buying products from the company’s advertisers. And if a few of them kill themselves along the way? Eh, happens.Luckily for said users, Anna wasn’t standing for this and her refusal to accept that idea had put her in danger. Of course, Reese was there to save the day (multiple times), and Fusco even got in on the act with a nice left cross to take down Calvin. All things considered, this story wasn’t anything too spectacular, but it was solid nonetheless.
Odds and ends:
- Root was back, albeit for what felt like a fraction of a second. That didn’t stop her taking out four Samaritan operatives and shooting Claire (in the same shoulder that she had previously been shot in) and save Finch.
- I liked how they tied Fetch and Retrieve to Samaritan at the end. It was kind of obvious that it was going to happen, but interesting to see and it’s another step towards Samaritan taking over the world.
- Claire dropped an iPhone onto the ground and it didn’t break? Totally unrealistic.
- Was it just me, or did Claire have a hint of an Australian accent whenever she said “Samaritan”?
- “Cross could use some work.” “Stand him up, I’ll go again.”
So, what did you think of this episode? Did you suspect Claire was still Samaritan from the beginning? Let me know your thoughts on the episode in the comments below, and check out the promo for the next episode, ‘Blunt’ below.
.JPG)
Root came for a split second and she killed it.
ReplyDeleteDid anyone doubt for a second that Claire was planted ? And what I came away with is that Root is still Queen of Awesome.
ReplyDeleteLiterally :)
ReplyDeleteFrom the first moment Claire showed up I was saying "Don't trust her Harold!! She a Samaritan agent!!" P.S. Root saving the day was the best part of the show. <3
ReplyDeleteVery solid episode, and one that seems even stronger in hindsight.
ReplyDeleteI didn't suspect Claire, because I thought that her apparent situation made sense, that her disillusionment with Samaritan at that point would've been as believable as her actual loss of faith near the end. The flash drive may have allowed for a major move against Samaritan, or at least provided new insight.
I think faith/belief was the central idea. In Anna's story, this was shown as Jill's faith in her over technology: "If she had asked VAL, instead of me..." Claire was right about what Finch wanted to believe (I wanted to believe the same). Finch's losses of Ingram and (especially) of Dillinger are similar to his last scene with her in Nautilus. He likely decided he didn't want to lose another person whose actions or fate hinged on him. I think he may also have been reminded of Root in that exchange, especially since Root herself pointed out that she and Claire have similarities.
That's what always fascinating to me, the hows and whys of the story. And the show's built up its mythos so much that it seems like references and parallels are everywhere.
I had the distinct impression that Samaritan likes this app because it will help 'purge' the undesirables.....mentally ill, physically disabled, etc.....gives them the means and the impetus to kill themselves..............just list sending the way to commit suicide to someone cry out for help to prevent suicide......wrong meds for the wrong symptoms.....
ReplyDeleteThis is a valid possibility, though IMHO the reason why Samaritan did this was only that there were clearly controllable results of his "behavioural tests". His avatar told Root that he needs people, he needs the humankind to exist and operate. But at the same time they mustn't know that they are not only watched but manipulated too. So he needs intermediary agents (like the falsely elected governor) and more importantly subtle mass manipulation means.
ReplyDeleteMost people doesn't trust 100% in what they hear or see in the news - but if they get the same answers on the net for multiple different searches, they will accept it the right one.
Even more than one it... ;-)
ReplyDeleteProbably not... Even if you were to ignore everything else – right from
ReplyDeletethe moment when Harold went to the coordinates for the meeting with Claire Samaritan operatives had eyes on them, which means that if they wanted to kill
both Claire and Harold... they would.
Yep, I'd be inclined to agree with that assessment. Samaritan wants to help the world by removing undesirables (e.g. in the case of the food and water shortages) so this will only help it.
ReplyDelete