As I successfully predicted in my review last week, 'The Crossing' said goodbye to Officer/Detective Joss Carter - and did so in sublime fashion. In true POI style, the phone ringing as Simmons arrived to kill Reese and Carter was the call of death (much like the four knocks in Doctor Who).
Her relationship with John had just hit a new high: the two reminiscing, sharing stories, Reese telling Carter that it was she that saved his life, a kiss and John expressing his happiness that Carter was with him at the (potential) end of his life. Instead, the tables were turned and it was he who was there for her. The interaction between these two had drastically changed since the pilot, something that was a work in progress until now. These recent episodes left the pair all set for a potential relationship.
The final scene with her was pure perfection. Going back to the root of her first encounter with Reese, quoting the exact same speech was incredible. It was fitting that virtually her last moment with him was a repeat of her first with him. His concern for her despite his own wounds, and his pure emotion flowing out of him as she died made this scene the best I've seen this TV season. Credit has to go to the POI writers for making her farewell so fantastic.
In fairness, her storyline seemingly had nowhere to go. Having taken down (most of) HR, the group responsible for Cal's death, Laskey's death, the torture of Fusco, along with the endless amounts of crime they had committed, her auxiliary focus had been completed. Taylor's father returning to the picture last week meant that he'll have a father - so everything about Carter had ended.
The death comes after Alonzo Quinn had been handed into FBI custody, while all but one of HR had been arrested. That elusive person, the one who has evaded capture longer than any HR member, was the one who proved to be the main bad guy. Simmons seems to see himself as the head of HR, even if that position is filled by Quinn. Although likely relayed from Quinn, he's always the one giving the orders; not afraid to get his hands dirty and lead.
Speaking of Fusco, I was glad that he survived. His sarcastic remarks towards Simmons, even when his life was in danger was brilliant. The strength he showed to hold out against some brutal torture, as well as using said torture as a means to get himself free really showed how he has progressed as a character. The pilot showed him as a weak, easily controllable HR cop. Now, he has transformed himself into someone who will do whatever it takes to complete the cause he believes in.
The emotional scene he had with his son was brilliant - as was his reaction upon hearing Shaw's voice. Like Reese, he showed that he doesn't care if HR killed him, as long as his son was safe. This was a fantastic moment, one that showed just how much Fusco cares for his son. Shaw, who seemingly dislikes Fusco, still did what was necessary for him. She made a difficult choice to save his son instead of him, assuming that it's what he'd want. I think that even Shaw felt bad about not going to save Fusco, but even if he had died, she would have been able to take comfort in the fact that she saved his son.
Some other bits:
- How did no one inside the precinct hear the shots?
- Finch is at serious risk of being hit by a car at the end. And, speaking of him, it was trademark Finch to be standing around with no clue what to do after Carter was shot.
- I presume this is the big thing Root was talking about a few episodes back. I wonder how much of an advanced role she'll get now after Carter's death.
- "Breakfast." "It's 4 in the morning."
- How predictable was it that Reese would win the fight against those guys on the subway?
- Shaw breaking into Fusco's house was awesome. "You know the dog's the only one that likes you right?"
- "I was told there's a chance to shoot people." We meet the HR version of Shaw.
- Fortune cookie story-time was fantastic.
- Shaw is totally insane. It isn't every day that a presumed dead rogue places a live grenade in the hands of an HR cop and throws away the pin.
- If only Reese had had his gun.
- This image of Fusco - what's happening to him? He's like an animal!
Overall, this episode was the best POI yet. I thought last week's was good, but it was NOTHING compared to this. Every moment was undeniably incredible. I knew they were going to kill off a main character - but I was still shocked to the core when they actually did it. Next's week ending of the three-part event (and midseason finale) is likely to be just as good. Get the promo below. I hope Reese ends Simmons. With multiple bullets. And a grenade launcher. He deserves it.
I'll be posting a Carter's best bits article at the weekend, so look out for that. All that's left to say is RIP Joss Carter. You will be sorely missed.
Now that's a good review title. . The other one spoiled the episode for me
ReplyDeleteIt was truly a mind blowing episode in every sense of the word
This was the most phenomenal episode of the whole series. ..
The writers have some serious guts pulling off an episode like this
Shaw never disliked Fusco; she just can't deal with emotions, remember? In fact, I think Shaw relates to Fusco more than to any other member of Team Machine...because, like her, Fusco is also a little broken (due to his past as a crooked cop).
ReplyDeleteGreat review. Carter was a fantastic character, and she got what she wanted, it's sad to see her go, but I appreciate when the writers and producers take this kind of risks, like Taraji Henson said "art imitates life. Sometimes the good guys lose..", or in this case, she won but it came with consequences.
ReplyDelete- I wonder also how is it that no one heard the shots, they were like, what, half a block away from the precinct?
- And you say that it's Finch's trademark to just stand there, I was screaming inside my head "finch move!! call an ambulance or something!!"
- And are we sure the phone ringing was Carter's number? The machine usually makes the call earlier, and it kept ringing even after Carter was dead, unless it was just for the scene to have more impact.
I like a show with guts - changing things that seem utterly insane. Otherwise it's boring.
ReplyDeleteThat's an interesting opinion. I hadn't even considered that. Tbh I think Shaw has a problem with anyone she isn't allowed to shoot.
ReplyDeleteThanks. Carter was awesome. Can't believe she's gone.
ReplyDeleteHalf a block? That's generous. I'd say 50 feet.
Yeah, Finch seems to freeze up in bad situations.
I think it was her number. Not sure who else's it could have been. And the phone kept ringing because Finch hadn't answered it.
Yeah, maybe, but I think that's because violent action is the only method she has available to her, at all, to express emotions.
ReplyDeleteI think she didn't dislike him, she disrespected him - just like everybody else to be honest. (Carter started to respect him in the end of the last season, but even when she stole Simms body I'm not sure how much she was convinced that he deserved that help. She wasn't sure he deserved the punishment and it was enough for her (being a Paragon) to make the move, but it was more about her conscience.)
ReplyDeleteAt the same time Fusco was the only one who Shaw has a common attitude with. Both of them do good with grumbling, not really undertstand themselves why do they do these things for other people.
Like I said, they're both broken...they have common ground.
ReplyDeleteGreat review again, Bradley!
ReplyDelete"In fairness, her storyline seemingly had nowhere to go. Having taken down (most of) HR, the group responsible for Cal's death, Laskey's death, the torture of Fusco, along with the endless amounts of crime they had committed, her auxiliary focus had been completed. Taylor's father returning to the picture last week meant that he'll have a father - so everything about Carter had ended."
Although I can accept the idea of a symbolic change "if" her death is used well, I don't necessarily agree with this, because it's not like she also didn't have a military background or that she hadn't been a good team player for Team Machine. It's not that I disagree that the way things have been written this season don't point to her end, but rather I don't think things necessarily had to end. I think there was still potential story with her character and background.
For me what I think the episode and the mini arc with this 3 episode block might be telling us is that this isn't a good or fair world, and although I think the truth is we will never really know, the episode also went out of it's way to give Finch and option he chose not to take, allowing us to forever mill over a potential variable ---but moreover, characters like Root and Shaw may be very much needed in times ahead, as I suspect her death also marks a story and/or mythos game changer...perhaps getting back to that unknown character introduced in "glove" in the season 2 finale...
I agree. As an old-school type of crime fighter (i.e., police detective) Carter was something like a representative of rationality...someone who kept Team Machine grounded in the everyday world. If Root is now set to gain a more important role in Team Machine, then I think we might now really see the show drifting in a more scifi-like or mystery-like direction, where longer story arcs phase out the case-of-the-week shows that made up most of the first two seasons of the show. But, I've said that before, haven't I?
ReplyDeleteMaybe it's Simmons number...I don't think he'll make it next episode.
ReplyDeleteHe will die next week. I'm sure of it.
ReplyDeleteExactly! I think if we start to get more and more serialized with some kind of new threat emerging will make this turning point a lot more acceptable.It would be neat if we could tread a little more sci-fi.
ReplyDeleteOne thing that I like and what is different from something like Almost Human, is how this artificial intelligence story has a Dues Ex Machina quality to it since the machine is often "off stage" and also acts more of a collective conscience rather than looking at one advanced being, but I feel like if the show wants to keep moving they will have to move away from ominous being and challenge us with a more humanized perception of the machine, which is why I do think that is where the Root storyline is leading or venturing more into. :)
Great review. Looking forward to Carter's best bits article.
ReplyDeleteAnother tidbit -- you are stuck in the morgue four blocks from the FBI building, with proof of criminality on record that Finch can play over a phone, under threat from rogue cops (some of whom the FBI busted just last year) and thugs and ... you don't pick up a phone and call the FBI for help?
ReplyDeleteThis episode was shot through with plot holes and lazy, cheap emotional cliches. A lot of fans are angry, and a lot feel cheated. POI has Taraji out on every possible outlet trying to do damage control today; they clearly anticipated blowback. I wonder if they anticipated how many people are just going to change the channel.
It's not lazy if the point is that the reality the series isn't a fair or a good one. There were a few messages it could give off, including a potential avenue not explored via Harold's choice (or lack there of).
ReplyDeleteWe have two promoted female leads this year who are deadly killers and this end to Carter might point out their value or need, which could really launch interesting emotional arcs for everyone left, let alone challenging the viewers with the possibility of preferences the machine could have and it's potential flaws...
And honestly life is a cliche; and not all cliches are bad or not true. I don't feel the emotions were cheap. I think the relationship between Reese and Carter has been there all along, but more over she represents a heart and soul, which is one reason why her death is SO painful for some fans. She was the heart and soul. The "good" character that in a kinder world, didn't deserve to die...
"I was told there's a chance to shoot people." We meet the HR version of Shaw.
ReplyDeletePriceless!
Root is out! Oh Dear!
ReplyDeleteIm hoping they let Root out i don't feel like she is the villain they make her out to be i think she can become a major asset
ReplyDeleteYYYYYYAAAAAAYYY lol, can you tell im a fan
ReplyDeleteJudging by the promo for the next episode, they will. I'm guessing that, in the future, we'll see a lot of Fusco paired up with Shaw and Root paired up with "the Big Lug."
ReplyDeleteYou were still shocked that they actually killed off a main character. In a way, I love that. That demonstrates why POI is unique and unlike any other show on TV. It kills off a main character in mid season instead of doing it in the finale. Nice review.
ReplyDeleteThanks. It's a week on and I'm still in shock. Ask me in May, I'll probably still be in shock. Seriously bold move to kill off a main character.
ReplyDelete