Arrow 2.02 "Identity" Review: Yin and Yang
Oct 18, 2013
Arrow ReviewsThis week’s episode of Arrow, “Identity,” was written by Ben Sokolowski and Beth Schwartz and directed by Nick Corpus. The episode features some good stunts and fight scenes and ends with one heck of a cliffhanger. We also get some gimmick arrows! My favorite was the tazer arrow. As we’ve come to expect of the show, it carries the theme of identity throughout the episode in several storylines and with a few different implications.
Oliver (Stephen Amell) is still struggling with balancing both his identities, as are Felicity (Emily Bett Rickards) and Diggle (David Ramsey). I loved the scene in which Felicity and Diggle are both dissatisfied with their new alter-egos. Felicity insists that MIT over qualified her to be Oliver’s executive assistant and Diggle is not happy to be the “black driver.” Meanwhile, Oliver struggles to find his feet as CEO of Queen Consolidated and make amends to the people of the Glades. Of course, he’s not helped by alderman Sebastian Blood (Kevin Alejandro), who seems determined to publicly humiliate Oliver at every turn. In another theme that runs throughout the episode, Blood tells Oliver that he sometimes lets his emotions get the better of him. He certainly seems to have a vendetta against the Queens. We see Roy in the present question whether anything makes Oliver angry, and Oliver cautions Roy on letting his anger consume him.
Crusade 2.0 is proving a bit more difficult for Oliver because he doesn’t have the list to rely on, but an old nemesis – China White (Kelly Hu) provides their first target. She brings a new friend to help her – Bronze Tiger (Michael Jai White). Meanwhile, Oliver is also trying to be a better friend to Diggle. Felicity and Diggle have obviously grown closer while Oliver was away and she has grown in confidence enough to scold Oliver for not even realizing that Diggle and Carly have broken up. Diggle is having trouble reconciling the two sides of himself too and points out to Oliver that having an alter-ego and hunting down Deadshot comes with a price.
Oliver has firsthand experience of that price. Laurel (Katie Cassidy) is prepared to be a good friend to Oliver while dedicating herself to bringing the Vigilante to justice. It’s very telling, in fact, that she refers to him as the Vigilante, blaming him for Tommy’s death. Of course, she ignores the fact that had Laurel herself gotten herself to safety before the quake, Tommy would also still be alive. Laurel tells Roy (Colton Haynes) that the Hood only acts like he’s your guardian angel. Her judgment on the Hood’s identity has been clouded by the events of the quake.
Meanwhile, Roy is also struggling to decide who he is going to be. This was the first episode that I felt we really got to see Haynes add some layers to Roy, and I’m a lot more interested in seeing more of him after this. Thea (Willa Holland) gives Roy an ultimatum – stop putting himself in danger or get out of her life. In a nice nod back to the first season, she gives him the Hozen that Oliver gave her as a symbol of reconnecting. The Hozen is a buddhist symbol associated with the arrow. It symbolizes the reconnecting of friends or the meeting of true friends. It also symbolizes the destruction of the passions. It is also associated with the bow and arrow which are symbolic of intense concentration. The union of the bow and arrow can also symbolize love. All of this symbolism resonates with this episode that focuses on the control of passion and the role of love – how both love and passion can be barriers to concentration. It can also be seen as a symbol of connecting the two facets of the individual – the yin and yang in each person.
The flashbacks show Oliver finding the Hozen and beginning to conquer his anger and his inner demon. This storyline is also the touchstone between Oliver and Roy as Oliver recognizes that Roy is very much in the same place Oliver was in on the Island, and as Shado (Celina Jade) offers to teach him, Oliver takes Roy under his wing. In an attempt to protect Roy and teach him to be safer, the Hood asks Roy to be his eyes and ears in the Glades to bring him information. Roy goes back to Thea and tells her he’s done trying to be a hero – which of course, he isn’t really.
Wilson (Manu Bennett) tells Shado after Oliver kills the soldier with his bare hands that he’s seen men in war with the same look and Oliver is splitting into two people, one he doesn’t even recognize. He asks Shado to talk to Oliver before the anger tears him apart. Oliver confesses to Shado that he feels like the Island is turning him into something terrible, but Shado tells him the Island can’t make him something he’s not. She tells him there are opposing forces in everyone – darkness and light, killer and hero. Shado washes the blood from Oliver and then they make love. Wilson, meanwhile, after sending Shado to Oliver later tells him not to fall too hard for Shado because she’s a distraction that will get him killed. In contrast to Shado, Wilson tells Oliver that the Island is having an effect on him. A triangle can never end well, and it seems Wilson is conflicted about having Shado and Oliver grow closer.
In another nice echo of the first season, the local newscaster points out that the question everyone is asking themselves is not “where have you been Oliver Queen, but what have you done for us lately.” Oliver’s attempts to help are stymied because his two identities need to be in two different places at the same time. He has to choose between attending his charity function or saving a medical shipment. China White tells him he’ll always be a criminal to the authorities – he’ll never be a hero. Oliver tells her it doesn’t matter as long as the city is safe.
There’s a nice moment between Diggle and Oliver at the end of the episode when Oliver apologize for not being there for Diggle when he needed him. Diggle offers to drive him home, but Oliver tells him he’ll “find his own way” home. And in a larger sense, Oliver is making his own rules and carving his own way to help Starling city. The scene ends with Felicity bringing Oliver a coffee – a nice symbol of how she does take care of him – but as part of the team, not as a simple employee.
The Hood visits Laurel twice. The first time he tries to explain that he isn’t her enemy, and reminds her that she used to think he was helping. Laurel tells him she blames him for Tommy’s death, for being a coward, and for not protecting the people he’d told her he’d protect. The Hood returns to Laurel after stopping China White... and walks right into a trap. I can’t wait until next week to find out how Oliver is going to get out of this one!
What did you think of the episode? Who do you think poses the biggest threat to Oliver now – Bronze Tiger, Sebastian Blood, or Laurel? Do you think Oliver can keep Roy out of trouble and danger? Let me know your thoughts in the comments below.
Sign Up for the SpoilerTV Newsletter where we talk all things TV!
Hey. Great review. and thank you for the explanation behind the arrow that Oliver gave Thea and Thea gave Roy. I knew it must have some simbolic meaning, but I had no idea what.
ReplyDeleteI loved the episode. As an Olicity fan it had great moments, but what was the most interesting part for me was Roy's road to became red arrow and how he's now joined the team (in a way).
The second visit to Laurel caught me by surprise. I thought Oliver would listen to her when she said not to come back. But I don't get the Laurel now hates the Hood thing. I don't actually understand how she could change her mind SO much. If it was simply a I dislike him now because he didn't help my friend, but no, now she sees him as a treat to the city and will do anything to stop him from doing the good she knows he can do.
I think Laurel poses the most immediate threat, but as this season continues, I think Sebastian Blood has the most potential to become one of this season's two big bads. My guess is that Blood is also the brain behind this drug stealing operation, and I think he'll cause more damage to both Arrow and Oliver this season.
ReplyDeleteRoy will definitely find himself back in trouble again, and probably soon..
I have mixed feelings about this episode.
ReplyDeleteThe writer's tried doing too much once again, but unlike 2x01 this time the story suffered for it. And Really! After the first FEMA truck carrying medical supplies was attacked, there's no way the drivers would continue to work or the state police wouldn't have escorted the truck.
Not a very smart move from Oliver to go back and visit Laurel after what she told him the first time he visited her. Obviously, this episode suffers from several inconsistencies and while I usually don't mind as long as it serves the plot, the episode was weakened by them in this case.
Allow me to reproduce my advices to support the show and help it get better ratings:
If you want to help the show get the best possible ratings, it's best if you watch it LIVE at 8pm and DVR the other shows sharing the same timeslot; if you recorded it, it's best if you watch it the same day (instead of watching it 1 or 2 days later). Of course, feel free to spread the word about the greatness of the show around you and on social networks such as Twitter or Facebook. Even if you don't live in the US, speaking about the show on social networks will help to generate and amplify the buzz, all the more so networks have tools to measure the online activity surrounding a show.
Summer Glau's Isabel Rochev's comes back in episode four, 'Crucible', and hopefully in episode three.
Nice review. Thank you for writing this. I like what they're trying to do this season, however, it was a bit strident that Oliver can't catch a break at every moment as well as Laurel's insistence that Tommy's death was all the Vigilante's fault. I get that the hero is supposed to be burdened, but it was laid on pretty thick here. Also, there is no explanation of why Oliver was late to his benefit. I would rather he had been there, on time -- which we've seen him do plenty of times in the past. His being called away could have been frustrating to the Alderman but just having the guy go out there and lambast Oliver, amongst Oliver's friends and in the man's office, was pretty heavy-handed.
ReplyDeleteThe team interactions were good, no real complaints here. The island bits were superfluous, and I never thought that last season. But Shado and Oliver having sex so soon after the fight and the killing was silly and the usual low-brow stuff I expect from the CW when it lowers its already pretty low standards. Arrow doesn't usually resort to such stuff -- Oliver's and Laurel's indiscretion at the end of season 1 notwithstanding.
I agree whole-heartedly with your assessment of Laurel and her judgment's against the vigilante. I think the writers are trying to improve over last season's portrayal of her, but they haven't quite got it yet. Making her blame the vigilante for Tommy's death really just shows her in a poor light. As others have stated: she was fine with the vigilante when he was helping her. She also didn't even seem to question the reason of why the vigilante was in the CNRI headquarters. Gee, Laurel, did it occur to you that the vigilante got there to try to save you, found Tommy already dead, and was leaving because try as he might, he wasn't able to be there in time? As you pointed out, it was Laurel's refusal to leave the dangerous situation -- stay out of the building, silly people, you can rebuild your cases; but, lose your lives and they're gone forever -- that resulted in Tommy's death. The vigilante had nothing to do with it.
Great review. thanks for letting me write my own thoughts. :-) I'll be looking forward to more of your reviews.
Thanks - and your welcome! I had to find out more about the hozen when it came up again in an episode.
ReplyDeleteI agree about Oliver going back to see Laurel - it does seem stupid, but then, I think Oliver is just as confused as we are by how much she has changed how she feels about him. I hope that we will get some indication of what has changed her mind so much. I wonder if her new boss has been telling her things about Oliver that aren't true? Mainly, I think it is a deflection of her own guilt. I mean, realistically, Tommy was impaled on an iron bar - there was absolutely no way for the Hood to save him... The show is too tightly written not to give us a better explanation for Laurel's complete change of heart.
I agree on all accounts. I hadn't thought about Blood being behind the drug operation. The said it was the Triad - but maybe he is involved with them somehow?
ReplyDeleteGreat advice to help the show! Nielsen is actually tracking twitter traffic for 3 hours before and after the hour the show airs.
ReplyDeleteAs to the inconsistencies... I think the fact that the police aren't escorting the trucks is more evidence that the city has written off the Glades - they are more willing to put manpower on catching the Hood than saving citizens. Maybe we'll also find that the city is getting kick backs from the crooks... As for Oliver going back to Laurel? I think her severe change of heart is not believable to him - or us for that matter - at this point - it needs more explanation. The fact that he goes to see her in her office where it is very easy to trap him is a stupider mistake on his part, I think...
Definitely looking forward to how Isabel is going to shake up Oliver's world...
Thanks - and great points! I thought the Island scenes provided some insight into what was happening in the present - and I think we will see a better reason for those scenes as we go forward. I was bothered by why Oliver was late too. And more troubling was that he was IN the building - why not just stick your head in and say you have an emergency? That was stupid - or call Blood - or... a number of other solutions besides just not showing up!
ReplyDeleteBronze Tiger was mentioned as part of the suicide squad in the spoilers, so I think it was a partnership between the Triad and the suicide squad, and I think Blood is one of the suicide squad's members. It seems like he would also try to get more resources while trying to gain control and influence over the Glades, and trying to present himself as a crusader fighting for the survival of the Glades.
ReplyDeleteI think that Laurel just moved from "bland and useless" to "annoying". And I think that the Thea/Roy subplot was the only thing I really enjoyed in this episode. And that I hope that Felicity will go back to a wardrobe which is more "her" as soon as possible.
ReplyDeleteThe biggest threat for Oliver is currently his own stupidity.
Great review Lisa. What I'd like to see is what would happen if Oliver revealed himself to Laurel. Her dilemma then would be a serious battle.
ReplyDeleteNice review, but I have to say I thought this was a pretty weak episode, for many of the reasons other commentators have already hit on. Plot contrivance rather than logic or consistency seemed to dominate. Certainly, if FEMA trucks were consistently being ambushed and the drivers killed, there is no way, regardless of how the cops felt about helping out the Glades, that FEMA or any responsible organization would allow those trucks to be sent in unaccompanied by some sort of guard. Ollie getting cvalled away from the benefit at the last possible second: dual-identity cliche that could hvbe been dealt with far more plausibly. Sebastian Blood ... well, we can be reasonably sure he's going to be the villainous Brother Blood, but so far he's pretty implausible as what we're supposed to see him as: a concerned politician. Pubicly slagging a fabulously wealthy guy who just ran a benefit to raise funds four your pet cause--even if that guy didn't show up himself--is simply idiotic. And Laurel . . . well, I blamed that nitwit from the time it happened for Tommy's death. I hope (but doubt) that she will eventually figure out that he rown moronic stubbornness about saving file folders is the real cause of his death, not the Hood not being there (crazily enough, becaus he was focusing on trying to stop the actual architect of the disaster, not tooling around rescuing every Tom dDck and Harry he could find), but then, without this amazingly contrived antagonism, we wouldn't have enough melodrama. Would it really have been so hard, btw, for the the Hood to, you know, mention he was trying to save Tommy but was too late? Blerg. Disappointing episode.
ReplyDeleteYep. I'm remembering the suicide squad mentions now - definitely think this is the way they are going!
ReplyDeleteCan't say that I'm a big fan of where they are taking Laurel this season so far. They taunt us with great moments like her disarming the guy last week and then have her make this about face on the Hood.
ReplyDeleteThanks! I think it's inevitable that Laurel will find out Oliver's alter-ego, but it's too soon!
ReplyDeleteI personally think we'll see The Hood saving Laurel again and her second guessing her hatred towards him before we'll see Oliver revealing himself to her. I think the writers want her to hit rock bottom this season, lose her faith in the law, and decide to become a vigilante. I still hope she makes her own decisions before she find out about Oliver's secret but I guess we'll find out..
ReplyDeleteI'm not a big fan of it but don't hate this development either. I find Laurel interesting now, I think KC plays the character better, and she's now more than the token love interest. It might not be what I'd wanted for her, but for now, I do think it's working for me.
ReplyDeleteThat's where I disagree...she is still just written as the love interest, because her whole chase wouldn't matter much if she weren't the one Oliver loves. If she were able to trap him because she is a competent chaser, this might work better, but the only reason she can trap him at all (and this certainly won't last long) is because he is in love with her. The only thing she managed this episode was not listening to Roy when he mentioned other vigilantes and ignoring the fact that the hospital getting what it needs might be more important than catching the hood (even her father got his priorities right when it came to this stuff).
ReplyDeleteI think the only story-arc she EVER had on her own in this show and in which she didn't ultimately ended up as a damsel in distress and/or acted like a moron was when her mother came to town (which was easily her best episode).
He didn't have to mention it because she said she saw him on the scene...she is basically angry with him because he tried to made sure the Merlyn didn't set of the devices remotely and came too late instead of spending his whole day keeping an eye on her and Tommy just in case she gets the brilliant idea to risk her life with a stupid move.
ReplyDeleteYeah, but wasn't the implication that she saw him on the scene and BLAMED him for Tommy's death--as if the Hood had done it? Maybe not, as the logic of her position simply escapes me, but still, you'd think he might have just mentioned ,"Hey! I TRIED to save him, and I wouldn't have HAD TO do so if you weren't dumber than a bag of hammers!" (OK, maybe not that last part.)
ReplyDeleteBut the only reason every character in this show exist is to support Oliver. Diggle and Felicity don't have any plot for themselves, they are just there because Oliver needs them. Roy just have his plot beucase he wants to be like Oliver. Thea and Moira are there just to be the Queen Family.
ReplyDeleteThe only thing she knows is that the Hood was fighting Malcom Merlyn and after that she saw Merlyn's son dead and the Hood leaving. She can't know why he was there. She only knows he was, and he didn't help Tommy. And she didn't ask tommy to save her, in case you don't remeber. She doesn't need to do everything people say to her. She was there trying to help the people she had to: her clients. She didn't know what would happen there.
ReplyDeleteLove interest is the dirtiest word in fandom, didnt you know. It doesnt matter if you have other roles in the show to play
ReplyDeleteDiggle and Felicity can be servants to Ollie 24/7 with no life of their own and they would still be worshipped in this fandom
Its not too soon at all he revealed himself to Diggle, Felicity whom he didnt even know that much, by episode 3 and 14. Helena and Tommy also knew his secret ID. And it looks like Roy will know soon.
ReplyDeleteBut he cant tell his remaining best friend and the woman he wants to be with the secret, if she doesnt find out this season as well as Thea and Moira, they would be stalling unnecessarily and stretching too much.
You're right, she can't know. Pretty stupid of her therefore to assume the worst, isn't it? I mean, absent anything approximating evidence? Did she think the Hood, who has consistently killed folks with his bow and arrow, suddenly took to impaling them on rubble? Did she forget that the building had just collapsed moments before, and she'd barely got out with her life? Is her job not to examine evidence closely and reach conclusions based on the evidence, not assumptions? (Rhetorical questions; obviously, her job is to use the law to pursue personal vendettas without regard to evidence or sense.)
ReplyDeleteAnd equally stupid of him not to bother with an explanation. But then, the point is for there to be conflict between them, not for either of them to behave sensibly. My ppoint is that that conflict could have been created a heck of lot more plausibly. This is just poorly thought through.
She didn't kow what would happen there? She was told, repeatedly, that disaster was imminent. It was on the news, for Pete's sake. And she's in there shuffling files around. The building collapses. Her ex-boyfriend was in there when it went down, because he was trying to get her out. But it's the Hood's fault he's dead? Did the Hood make her stay there despite the grave peril? Did the Hood make Tommy go in the building? Is there any evidence that the Hood kills with rubble? This girl has serious avoidance issues.
Diggle has the whole story with his killed brother and his romance with Carly, as well as his traumatic past as war veteran. Roy and Thea have their entirely own subplot and in this case, the romance works to the advantage of the show, because it is not only well written, it also provides a good reason for Roy to even be there. Moira has a story of her own, the story how she tried to protect her family, how she lost Walter, her relationship with Thea. Even Felicity, despite having been only a recurring character last season, already got her own "mini-plot" so to speak with Walter. Naturally all those stories are eventually tie back to Oliver, he is the centre of the show after all, but they are not all just about him.
ReplyDeleteTake Laurel's cases. How often did we see her in a court room? Exactly once...to defend Oliver. How often did we see her succeed as a lawyer? I actually can't remember one single instance. She always had cases, but it was always "yes, she has cases, but she takes on people who are so powerful that she has next to no chance to win". Every time she has to fight her way out of a serious situation, she fails, so that the Hood can swoop in and rescue her. For example, when she had to protect the little boy (who should have been in protective custody either way after witnessing the killing of his parents), was there a reason why they couldn't allow her to chase away the murderer on her own the first time? No, they had to give her equipment failure, so that she has to get rescues again.
As I said, first season, I was mostly frustrated that she was written so bland. But her current shift of personality doesn't make any sense to me.
I think her guilt over Tommy and her hatred of the Hood would turn her against Oliver at this point.
ReplyDeleteDefinitely agree that she needs to make the decision to become a "hero" (vigilante is such a nasty word!) on her own...
ReplyDeleteLaurel has her sister's storyline, her father, her mother, her job. But you're a hater, so you can't see it. Good luck.
ReplyDeleteYou're right: the point is for there to ve conflict between them, not for either of them to behave sensibly. Laurel's hate is part of the show, like Oliver going to the island without thinking in his mother or sister. But people don't think this way. Most of Arrow viewrs only brings logical when we are talking about Laurel. There's lots of plots in this show that we can't explain, the don't make any sense. But I agree, they could do it more plausibly. Both Laurel and Oliver are acting weird because of Tommy...
ReplyDelete