The BBC have just announced that Peter Capaldi will be the new Doctor. See the Press Release
Let us know in the comments and by voting in the poll what you think.
POLL : What do you think of the choice for the New Doctor Who? + Promotional Photo
Aug 4, 2013
Doctor Who Polls
BBC have just released the first promotional cast photo of Peter Capaldi.
The BBC have just announced that Peter Capaldi will be the new Doctor. See the Press Release
Let us know in the comments and by voting in the poll what you think.
The BBC have just announced that Peter Capaldi will be the new Doctor. See the Press Release
Let us know in the comments and by voting in the poll what you think.
went with great, fantastic actor. Just concerned a lil at someone in their 50's I think.
ReplyDeleteAwesome. Love him
ReplyDeleteNever heard of him. But then I never heard of Matt Smith or David Tennant until Doctor Who. I"m looking forward to his run.
ReplyDeleteFantastic choice! He's a bit older, but certainly is charismatic and has the gravitas to play the Doctor! Excited to see him on Doctor Who!
ReplyDeleteLittle bit disappointed in terms of all the hype and it ends up being the one that has been mentioned for the last week. BUT I know he is going to be amazing because Capaldi is a class act.
ReplyDeleteHe's been in the show before, you seen Fires of Pompeii?
ReplyDeletegreat choice imo, can't wait to see him give his nuance to the Doctor
ReplyDeleteAwesome choice!! He's a brilliant actor. I'm really glad they chose an older actor this time...
ReplyDeleteThey went old school with this selection. Get ready for what will likely be a significantly different Doctor / companion dynamic than what people have gotten used to since the reboot.
ReplyDeleteI just looked him up on IMDB. He was in Torchwood: Children of Earth. I remember him now. He was simply brilliant in it.
ReplyDeleteNow I'm REALLY looking forward to him.
He was the best thing that ever happened to Torchwood in my book :)
ReplyDeleteNot who I was expecting, but I will give him a shot. This could go either way
ReplyDeleteYes!! I remember him from the episode "Fires of Pompeii" and I thought he was awesome. And from what I'm hearing, a lot of fans are also really excited about this!
ReplyDeleteNot surprised at all since all the bookies were betting on him. Not sure how I feel about him as the 12th doctor, but we'll see.
ReplyDeleteGreat chocie!!!
ReplyDeleteI wanted an older doctor. I enjoyed Smith but felt like the past few years the show has become a tad childish. I think with an older doctor he could have bit of a darker side (like the 9th doctor)
ReplyDeleteI actually like Capaldi, but I was hoping that TPTB would have the stones to cast someone who is not yet another white male.
ReplyDeleteI agree with everything you are saying, but I was really hoping for a female doctor or for a doctor of another ethnicity.
ReplyDeleteNothing surprising or worth talking about. Meh. We will see how he fits the role.
ReplyDeleteYeah. They made all the hype for what essentially was very safe and very expected casting.
ReplyDeleteI'm actually really interested to see how things are going to be like with this new Doctor. A whole new dynamics! And I wish him GOOD LUCK!
ReplyDeletegreat choice can't wait to see him in it.
ReplyDeleteWhy would someone in their 50's be a concern? The good number of the doctors have been over 50 and were adored by the fans. The Doctor is not supposed to be young just because some of the viewers are young.
ReplyDeleteHe;s not a little bit old. Look at Hartnell, Troughton and Pertwee. Until Matt Smith, the youngest Doctor was Davidson.
ReplyDeleteNot necessarily older, just someone who is capable of playing a "rougher" character.
ReplyDeleteEccleston had a certain charm of menace around him. Tenant had the whole silent darkness behind him. Matt Smith felt more like...Rabbit in Alice in Wonderland, leading his companions down the rabbit hole, hurrying erratic and not as dark as previous ones.
I doubt it will ever come to that, frankly. This casting, no matter how good actor is, has proven that BBC plays it safe, sadly.
ReplyDeleteMaybe once Moffat goes away from DR Who.
Possibly, but not necessarily. Alex Kingston is 50, and was the wife of a Doctor twenty years her junior; Chistopher Eccleston is 18/19 years older than his companion, Billie Piper, who was playing a few years younger than her actual age, widening the gap further. On top of that, the Doctor is over a thousand. Everybody's young compared to him anyway.
ReplyDeleteThat being said, it could be interesting to see if they will do something different with the companions. Whether we'll see more Donna/Ten sort of relationships, or even something more familial, with him acting as some sort of father figure to his companions. Or he could be just as flirty as ever. Which would be weirder for Clara (assuming she stays on as companion) - an older version of the Doctor who now treats her more like a daughter or favorite niece or something, or an older looking Doctor who flirts with her even more than the younger Doctor did?
That's what I like about the changing of the Doctors, really. No matter the casting, you're never quite sure what you're going to get, and how Capaldi's age will affect the Doctor's personality and relationships will be fun to see.
I think he'll be great. Loved him in Torchwood, thought he was brilliant, hopefully he'll be the same. Can't wait to see him now. Was still hoping it could have been Tennant but oh well :D
ReplyDeleteI don't see how. Donna was nothing like Rose, who was nothing like Amy in terms of their dynamics with The Doctor.
ReplyDeleteI don't expect they'll end the flirtation between Clara and the Doctor because of the age gap.
He may be old for 2013, though. This show has grown in part because of the demographic under Tennant and Smith. I don't know how that group, filled with fangirls, will tolerate a return to an older Doctor.
ReplyDeletePersonally, I'm neither for or against this. I dislike the idea of one actor playing three characters in the same universe, but I'll get over it.
No stunt casting The Doctor.
ReplyDeleteGreat choice picking Peter Capaldi... i can't wait to see the dynamic of Capaldi and Jenna Louise Coleman. I can't wait to hear is catchphrase. He'll be more a darker doctor just like Eccleston and also very mature. Very much different from Matt Smith.
ReplyDeleteI'm unrealistically praying that the BBC will let Capaldi play Malcolm Tucker from The Thick of It as the 12th doctor. The most foul-mouthed, badass Doctor of all time!
ReplyDeleteFor those who are unfamiliar, allow me to introduce you to Malcolm Tucker (Peter Capaldi). Viewer discretion is strongly advised. Seriously. This is really quite vulgar...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LugJd6uGJqI
Only two were in their 50's iirc? Back then it was a very different show thou, all three of the Doc's since the revival have complained how tough the filming schedule is and then there's the extras that also come with a role like this. Therefore I have my concerns that we could be looking at more split series or a short term 12th.
ReplyDeleteSuch an excellent choice. He is a great actor and I can't wait to see what he brings to the role.
ReplyDeleteI'm looking to see how things will change as well. Regardless of what changes and what doesn't, what I'm sure of is that Capaldi will do a good job.
ReplyDeleteThat would require them to actually AUDITION actors of another ethnicity to find out who is the best actor. The announcement of Peter Capaldi was clear that they had him in mind and didn't audition others. You can't be the best if you are not even allowed in the door.
ReplyDeleteThe fandom has been around since 1963, and every doctor has had fangirls. What made the fangirls attracted to them was the dynamic force of their personalities. You don't have to be young You have to be smart, witty, and capable of attracting a woman, not a little girl.
ReplyDeleteCall me naive, but I think they're holding off on that for story reasons. The Doctor can only regenerate twelve times, though we have heard there may be ways around that limit.
ReplyDeleteI think, and hope, they will pull the trigger on a female doctor or one of another ethnicity (or both?) when they reach that limit. If they continue this story that might happen in a few years, or if he lasts as long as Eccleston's doctor a whole lot sooner.
But that's just my opinion. :)
I mean... no, it's not the same.
ReplyDeleteDoctor Who is way bigger and has a way different fanbase now than it ever did in it's classic run.
that's exactly what i was thinking.
ReplyDeleteFantastic choice, he's always struck me as having great energy.
ReplyDeleteI love Peter Capaldi and am looking forward to see what he does with the Doctor role!
ReplyDeleteGreat analogy! XD
ReplyDeleteI always felt Smith lacked the gravitas of previous Doctors. Some had more than others of course, but Smith was just quirky and manic, no snark or menace.
I was very much hoping for an older doctor. I much prefer quirky and distinguished over quirky and childish. I would like to get back to what made the series great to start with.
ReplyDeleteThe magic screwdriver has gotten ludicrously over-powered in the last few years. They have used it to solve far too many problems. A Dalek with 2 sonic screwdriver arms would be the most powerful force in the universe. I am hopeful though, since they toned down the screwdriver a lot this year.
Uh... no, they auditioned Capaldi twice - and I'm absolutely certain he wasn't the only name on that list.
ReplyDeleteThat's the most important thing. People generally seem to be happy (or at worst, indifferent) to his casting, so that makes me happy. I haven't watched much of him outside of his one Doctor Who episode and his stint on Skins, so he's practically brand new to me. I kinda like it better that way, though. It's easier to think of him as the Doctor when I'm not remembering in other roles, on top of all the other Doctor's I'll inevitably compare him to.
ReplyDeleteMoffat basically said in the video during the announcement show that Capaldi was his pick all along.
ReplyDeleteAsk me again when we'll actually see him as the doctor ! However I think it's an interesing choice. We'll get used to him anyway. Just like for each one of the doctors.
ReplyDeletewhen matt smith was announced as the doctor i thought hmm wonder what clothe style hed be wearing
ReplyDeletethe same goes for the new doctor hes obviously well known hes no stranger to the scifi genre as hes been in doctor who and torchwood so hes pretty known and he was odds on favourite to get the role
me ive learned from my pre matt smith waiting and i admit i was like aaah this is gonna suck hes nothing like david tennant was
but then matt turned out to be quite brilliant so maybe he will be good
The story Moffat told was that he had had Capaldi in mind when Matt Smith was cast and when Matt quit Capaldi was the first name he came up with. He said he ran it by others on the team, asked Capaldi to come to his house to read for the part and when he was done they all agreed that he was the next Doctor. So one of the stories is wrong. They may have "auditioned" other actors to throw off the press, but Moffat said straight out that Capaldi was his choice from the word go.
ReplyDeleteHmm, you make a very good point. I hadn't looked at it this way. Hope is not lost, after all. (Not that I don't like Capaldi as the Doctor, I am just always appreciative of significant changes and innovation).
ReplyDeleteI think the beauty of Doctor Who is that the companion is the relatable one. The Doctor should always be 'alien' to us (not that people over 50 are alien but... you get it).
ReplyDeleteI don't know that there's ever a 'safe' choice for Doctor Who.
ReplyDeleteAnd, to be fair, he was only the favourite to be the Doctor as of last week. If we counted every suggestion since Matt Smith announced he was leaving, there would be absolutely zero unexpected choice.
Me too! Absolutely!
ReplyDeleteThis is just a feeling/idea I have, I might just as easily be wrong about it. :)
Preaching to the choir. :)
ReplyDeleteI was glad to see the screwdriver played down a bit in the latter half of this season. But it was still very noticeably overpowered.
A Dalek with two of them would just be overkill. xD
From what I can see, Capaldi's done a LOT of television. He knows the score.
ReplyDeleteThey should just destroy it like JNT did when he felt it was a crutch. Probably the only thing he did on the show that wasn't stupid.
ReplyDeleteIf they don't adapt, then we'll know the real reason they were watching the show. And goodbye to them, fare thee well, as far as I'm concerned.
ReplyDeleteHe got rid of K-9 too. Though I didn't mind K-9 nearly so much since he at least had a personality. The screwdriver is just a screwdriver.
ReplyDeleteIt is hard to destroy the thing now since they have established that they are so easy to make that even Amy can build one from scratch without ever having seen the inside of one.