Allow me to preface what I am about to say by admitting that I have had a lifelong love of movies bordering on obsession that is comparable only to rabid sports fans’ dedication to their favorite teams. That being said, I can admit that, in the grand scheme of life, movies really do not matter. They don’t. But, as true cinephiles, we love them anyway and allow their magic to alternately lift our spirits or dash our hopes because we allow them to occupy such a central position in our lives. So, when I say The Wolverine is an infuriatingly atrocious piece of garbage that rivals Gigli in its insipidness, I understand that my anger is as misplaced as it is wasted. (But I am pissed off.)
The latest attempt by 20th Century Fox to cash in on the most popular of Marvel’s X-Men, The Wolverine wastes what (in capable hands) would have otherwise been a fascinating and philosophical lost chapter of a beloved character’s life story. Director James Mangold (3:10 to Yuma, Walk the Line) essentially paint-by-numbers his way through the movie, perfunctorily aligning the requisite action set pieces without a coherent vision or semblance of emotion. The script is Frankensteined together, composed of contributions from screenwriters Scott Frank, Mark Bomback and Christopher McQuarrie – and who knows how many others – none of whom are able to make the plot workable or at all interesting. Instead, we get a dull, overthought story that never raises the audience’s pulse above a resting heart rate.
Falling vaguely between the events of X-Men: The Last Stand and the upcoming X-Men: Days of Future Past – and touching on some specifics from X-Men Origins: Wolverine without acknowledgement – The Wolverine has a tone of “I guess we’re doing this” at the start and it just gets worse from there. At the start of the film, Logan (Hugh Jackman) has exiled himself to the wilderness, no longer able to deal with what he’s done which, if you haven’t seen The Last Stand, will be a complete mystery to you. His John Rambo-esque living arrangements are disrupted when a mysterious young woman named Yukio (Rila Fukushima) tracks him down and tells him he must come to Japan for a reason that is unclear because Fukushima speaks like she has a mouth full of marbles.
Logan goes along with Yukio (because he is usually so acquiescent) and when they get to Tokyo he realizes he is there to say goodbye to a dying man named Yashida (Hal Yamanouchi) whom he saved from the atomic bomb dropped on Nagasaki during World War Two. Again, if you haven’t seen the previous films, you might think Logan was a vampire, but in fact, he is simply a mutant with incredible regenerative healing abilities. Mangold and his screenwriters have no time to give X-Men 101 lessons to their audience – despite that being extremely necessary in order to set up the film’s mythology – so they carry on as if everyone is familiar with Logan’s entire history.
Anyway. As a thank you for saving his life, Yashida claims he can make Logan mortal, thus ending the eternal torture of watching those around him die. Logan is skeptical, but after Yashida dies, Logan notices that he is no longer healing the way he used to and realizes Yashida was right. Despite this, Logan decides to protect Yashida’s granddaughter, Mariko (Tao Okamoto), from the Yakuza gang that is trying to abduct her and the two go off into hiding. Of course, the Yakuza are not the only ones trying to find them and they soon discover there was more to Yashida than just a vast corporate empire.
It is difficult to convey the terribleness of The Wolverine without a string of expletives. The movie fails on every level, from its asinine dialogue (see the trailer for evidence) to Fox’s shameless attempt to compete with Iron Man via a giant robot called the Silver Samurai which bears no resemblance to the villain from the comic books. Mangold is incapable of effectively filming action sequences which is unfortunate for us since the movie is essentially one obligatory set piece after another inundating the viewer. The rapid fire editing mixed with Mangold’s clumsy staging makes for a dizzying experience.
Possibly the biggest let down of the film is Jackman who, in Bryan Singer’s X-Men (2000), blew away every other actor on screen; Jackman was Wolverine. Here, he is a watered down version of the angry-but-loyal tough guy we’ve come to love. Logan is given no real motivation for his actions, especially those involving Mariko. He speaks in clipped sentences because the screenwriters can’t think of anything particularly witty or insightful for him to say. Focusing too much on Logan’s physical appearance, which is impressive, Jackman essentially sleeps his way through the film.
The Wolverine is a catastrophe from start to finish save a pretty exciting post-credit sequence that sets up Days of Future Past. The four-minute scene is the only time I wasn’t squirming in my seat and wishing for the pain to stop.
Grade: F
That surprises me. The trailer makes it seem better than the X-Men Origins: Wolverine prequel movie which was truly atrocious.
ReplyDeleteI knew this was going to be kind of bad but I didn't expect it to be THAT bad. Still I can't wait for Days of Future Past.
ReplyDeleteI honestly wish Fox would lose enough money on their adaptations to consider giving these properties back to Marvel. It is a shame to see them continually fail where I think others would succeed.
ReplyDeleteI love these sort of films usually but I must admit after seeing the trailer a few times I just couldnt get any enthusiasm to go see the film, after your report Im glad I didnt bother.
ReplyDeleteJust seeing the trailers made me think, "Haven't we already done this before?" I'm not a huge Wolvie fan but it just seems like we've been overdosed with Logan for the last 10+ years.
ReplyDeleteHm. Well that's a bummer, but as possibly the only person alive who thinks Logan/Wolverine is not even close to being the coolest or most interesting X-Man I'm not too disappointed, now I can wait until it's on On Demand.
ReplyDeleteI guess another reiew from someonewho goes on everything from Disney/MS Is gold and anything from Fox Is crap
ReplyDeleteGod, this review sucks lol. No offense but how many reviews have you written?
ReplyDeleteI mean, what I got most from reading it was that you were very angry. I didn't get the feeling that you analyzed the acting, directing, cinematography, etc.
ReplyDeleteIt looks good to me I wonuldn't go off of ONE review.
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry, but the review itself just isn't good. The entire thing reads like you went into this movie believing with every fiber of your being that it would suck, and then you started being overly critical about every single issue the movie had, no matter how small.
ReplyDeleteEvery review has personal opinions in it, but your review was SO personal that it fails to make people believe it's a bad movie because it is, or if it's a bad because you believed it would be a bad movie. This read more like a rant someone would post on a forum rather than a review that someone would take as good criticism.
It may be harsh, but if this thing was submitted to some place like Metacritic, nobody who knows a thing about writing or reading criticism would take it seriously.
SHUT THE FUCK UP PEOPLE!!! Go see the film YOURSELVES and fuck what this douchebag Matthew has to say about it. I, for one, can not WAIT to see it
ReplyDeleteWhy are people reading this one review and going 'oh, that's too bad! Guess it sucks then!' This is one review, I've read plenty of good ones.
ReplyDeleteNo need to be that rude!
ReplyDeleteim gonna go watch this on Cheap Tuesday where tickets are 6 dollars in Southern California, and gonna go knowing everything there is to know about X Man and Wolverine and anything else in that verse. And when i am done, i won't give a single Duck about any mistakes or changes or missing elements, and i will come out happy, knowing i watched something i wanted to watch. i pick before i watch and if i pick something i 98% of the times won't ever regret it. 2 % im talking about London Boulevard (only thing i can think of...ducking that movie even today i am pissed i picked to watch that).
ReplyDeleteDon't listen to him. Make up your own mind. I really enjoyed the film. It was emotional and complex and had some great action scenes, short though they may be. It's no masterpiece but it truly is an interesting and different take on Wolverine, and definitely the most personal one. Hugh is phenomenal in this one, and it's his best turn as Wolvie. Don't let others decide your opinion for you, do that yourself.
ReplyDeleteI got to admit i quite enjoyed this film
ReplyDeleteive seen better this year but still it had a good storyline as such so i disagree with the review
still fully look forward to days of fuitures past but compared to some of the past movies this is a good film
Saw the movie a few days ago, going to have to agree with poster.
ReplyDeletePoor setup (saw x3 like 5 years ago, or when ever that movie came out), so didnt remember the whole background exactly, but understood his motivations for wanting to die.
Wolverine wanting to help Maruko was not unexpected for this movie, but out of character for logan. The side charcters didnt came out very well as well ( + their motives), all in all a bad movie and it explains why I fell asleep at the end. :D
I actually liked it, and was expecting good reviews to come out.
ReplyDeleteas Joyce explained I am in shock that someone can get paid $4001
ReplyDeletein 4 weeks on the internet. have you read this web site ωωω.ℬuℤℤ14.ℂℴℳ
Great Personal Opinion there! Considering all the professional critics have gave the film ratings between 7.5's & 9's. which and forgive me if I'm wrong is probably the best reviews since X-2.
ReplyDeleteI tend to make up my own mind by watching it, rather than reading some random guys biased review on how he viewed it. Thankfully, not everyone shares the same opinions.
ReplyDeleteWow, I totally disagree with this review. I though it was a good movie, to be honest. Not excellent, not bad, just good. I'd give it an 7.5 maybe an 8.
ReplyDeleteThe story, the acting, the characters, the cinematography and the dialogue all are decent to good. Though nothing truly excelled.
It seems you went in ready to hate it and ended up hating it. That should be no surprise, next time try to go in with an open mind. Now you sound like an angry child, because the movie wasn't the movie you wanted.
I don't consider much of what either studio does to be "gold," actually.
ReplyDeleteDaniel-Please feel free to re-read the review and you'll see I addressed all of those components, though I did it briefly because the film did not warrant serious effort.
ReplyDeleteAnd I've been writing reviews for seven years. That doesn't mean I'm right, it just means I have plenty of experience.
Aydrian-I'm sorry to hear you didn't find the review to be good. My review was "so personal" because I couldn't objectively judge it (as I normally would) because it was offensively bad.
ReplyDeleteI actually went into the movie with very high expectations and with a lot of excitement. I was really rooting for Mangold/Jackman, but they let me down.
Excellent point, Connor! This is only one reviewers' opinion.
ReplyDeleteI completely agree, Charles, that people should make up their own minds. I'm glad you liked it. Personally, I hated it. And that's okay.
ReplyDeleteAs I mention above, I was super stoked about this movie and went in with high hopes. I have nothing against Kevin Feige and rarely consider a producer's role when predicting if a movie is going to be good or not.
Colin-You're right! It's getting very strong review. This is just my opinion. Of the people I talked to after the screening, I was definitely in the majority. But everyone has different ways of judging movies.
ReplyDeletePascal-I actually went into the movie expecting to love it. I love Jackman and Wolverine is my favorite X-Men character (because I'm really unique, lol). I do not pre-judge movies before I review them so I do have an open mind when I sit down.
ReplyDeletePerhaps because I was so excited that I'm extra angry about being disappointed. I feel like the filmmakers had a great opportunity here and they squandered it. But, I'm glad you liked the movie. Thanks for commenting.
Usually I agree with what you said. I think critics let Disney/Marvel slide a lot of crappy stuff.
ReplyDeleteI don't think this movie looks good and I'm sure Days of the Future Past is going to be a million times better than this.
I do too, but an opinion that has such outright hate for something was something I wasn't expecting. But everyone does indeed have their own opinions, and this review definitely didn't prevent me from going to see the movie.
ReplyDeleteI haven't yet seen the movie, but I fully intend to as soon as the local cinema has it showing. Reviews be damned :)
ReplyDeleteI would almost think you saw a different movie than I did. I'd definitely give it a 7.5, at least.
ReplyDeleteI'm surprised by this review. Mangold has proven himself to me a great director...
ReplyDeleteGranted I'm totally bias when it comes to X-men movies. I eat them up even if they suck. I mean I can acknowledge they suck, but I still like them.
What I'm trying to say is that I guess I'll be pleasantly watching this anyway...