The 2011 STV Character Competition - R1 - Day 3 - Jack Shepherd (LOST) vs. Sarah Walker (Chuck) & Castiel (Supernatural) vs. Malcolm Reynolds (Firefly)
Sep 2, 2011
2011 Character Cup Cancelled Shows SpoilerTV Article SupernaturalHey Guys,
Yesterday saw a convincing win for Peter Bishop over Patrick Jane seeing Fringe claim their first place in round two, and in a not all too surprising result Meredith Grey proved that having a bigger audience helps as she saw off Walter White from small cable show Breaking Bad. If it's any consolation for BB fans, to give the GA star such a close run was impressive itself.
Today is where the competition really cranks it up a notch as we have Jack Shepherd from LOST challenging Sarah Walker from Chuck as well as Castiel from Supernatural taking on Malcolm Reynolds of the short lived Firefly. All four shows have very passionate fans, and so it will be very interesting to see who comes out on top!
The prediction competition still has 71 people with perfect brackets. To see yours head HERE
All will be revealed today!
For anyone new to the competition The rules of the competition are simple. Every day there will be a new set of polls between characters who are bidding to become the winner of the second STV Character Competition.
All you have to do is to vote for whichever characters are your favourite and at the end of the 24 hours whichever character has more votes will be the winner and will progress into the next round. There are three rounds before the quarter finals, semi finals and then the final...
Don't forget to tweet, facebook, google+ and spread the word about the characters and shows you love to try and boost your chances of winning.
All that is left to say, is let the battles commence...
Round One
Jack Shepherd vs. Sarah Walker
Played By: Matthew Fox
Years Active: 2004-2010
Major Awards: Won 0 out of 1 Emmy Nominations. Won 0 out of 1 Golden Globe Nominations
Played By: Yvonne Strahovski
Years Active: 2007-present
Major Awards: No Nominations
Castiel vs. Malcolm Reynolds
Played By: Misha Collins
Years Active: 2008-present
Major Awards: No Nominations
Played By: Nathan Fillion
Years Active: 2002-2003, 2005(film)
Major Awards: No Nominations
Hope you all enjoy the competition and good luck to everyone.
Don't forget to tweet, facebook click and google+ all of the polls to help spread the word and try to help your characters reach the latter stages of the competition. Also check back tomorrow as Nikita takes on Chuck Bartowski as well as Caroline Forbes vs. Kate Beckett.
Twitter: @AdDHarris
Adam
Sign Up for the SpoilerTV Newsletter where we talk all things TV!
I'm voting Jack & Castiel!
ReplyDeleteI hope I get these right. I only got 2 points so far.
ReplyDeleteCrazy Jack and Malcom!
ReplyDeleteI had to choose between Castiel and Mal Reynolds?! That was tough.
ReplyDeleteJack & Cas.
ReplyDeleteJack and Mal. SpoilerTv has a huge supernatural fanbase but the last season may have lost Cas a few fans so I put Mal in my brackets (he did well last year too).
ReplyDeleteLOVE Mal but got to go with the Overlord Castiel on this one! SUPERNATURAL all the way!!
ReplyDeleteAdam I agree w/you. Can't go wrong with Jack! Lost was not just a show but a passion for me. Met Charlie at Comic Con. Talking to him brought all the greatness of Lost back to life. I love FireFly/Malcolm but I will always pick Castiel. He's my hero. I love when he would pop in to save the boys.
ReplyDeleteJack Shephard (probably among my three favorite character ever) and Castiel.
ReplyDeleteJack and Mal.. sexy reluctant heroes FTW!
ReplyDeleteVoted Sarah Walker (even though my bracket says Jack Sheppard) and Castiel.
ReplyDeletehehe, the same for me. I hoped that Mal could at least overcome this SN character.
ReplyDeleteJack (LOST) although I haven't seen neither Lost nor Chuck... and in 2nd poll... obviously Mal Reynolds!!!!!!!!!!!!! :D
ReplyDeleteJack ( even so I haven`t started to watch Lost yet ) and Castiel without a doubt! I do like Nathan Fillion and I have enjoyed his character Malcom Reynolds, but I can`t vote against Supernatural ;)
ReplyDeleteI've watched about 3 seasons from both Lost and Chuck and from what I've seen Jack gets my vote.
ReplyDeleteI haven't watched Firefly(yet),but I promise you that even if I had it wouldn't make a difference..
I can not physically vote against Castiel!It's impossible!
Voted Jack and Mal, but went with Jack and Cas in the bracket. I'm a fan of all 4 of today's characters, but Sarah has nothing on a character as fully developed as Jack and, while Cas is great, Mal is fantastic.
ReplyDeleteJack and Castiel (sorry Nathan love ya :P)
ReplyDeleteI love Sarah but obviously it is going to be Jack and definitely Castiel....
ReplyDeleteYeah you dont wanna piss off God
ReplyDeleteJack & Cas :p
ReplyDeleteLittle troubles with the first poll, but my choices are: Jack and Castiel
ReplyDeleteDefinitely not
ReplyDeleteSarah Walker and Mel
ReplyDeleteJack Shepherd and Castiel ;)
ReplyDeleteshepherd and Castiel (never seen firefly)
ReplyDeleteShepherd and Mal for me but I like all 4 fairly equally....
ReplyDeleteI had to vote for Sarah Walker but it was a tough choice. The easy one was voting for Captain Tight Pants, how can you not love Malcolm Reynolds.
ReplyDeletewalker and fillion :D
ReplyDeleteLooks like these polls are ruining my bracket , but that Castiel is losing is worse ;/
ReplyDeleteWOW at current result of the second poll!
ReplyDeleteMy votes go to Jack (only LOST character that I really love) and Cas (although I picked Malcolm over him in my bracket).
Jack Shepherd was not one of my favorite Lost characters, but I loved watching Lost and Jack gets my vote.
ReplyDeleteAawwww poor Cass^^; Voted for him...even if I admit what he did in the finale brought Balthy to my ''#1 Favorite angel'' spot....but Cas is a close second ;)
ReplyDeleteLets go Cass!!!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteCastiel is losing? Come on, Supernatural fandom, pick up the fucking pace.
ReplyDeletecastiel and sarah FTW!!
ReplyDeleteJACK AND CAS! HOW CAN YOU PICK ANYTHING ELSE?
ReplyDeleteCastiel forever :)
ReplyDeletethere - short shout out on twitter and Cas is in front XD
ReplyDeleteCastiel, of course <333
ReplyDeleteIt's ShephArd , not ShephErd.......
ReplyDeleteSupernatural fandom just woke up.lol
ReplyDeleteAs much as I adore Firefly and Nathan Fillion, he can't hold a candle in my eye to the amazing character of Castiel and the totally awesome Overlord Misha Collins!!!! Castiel all the way!!!
ReplyDeleteCome on guys Jack cant lose :/
ReplyDeleteObviously voted for Jack and then Castiel.
I vote for Jack (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EF-8yW6dEmY) and Castiel
ReplyDeleteJack and Castiel!
ReplyDeleteJack & Cas. Always. :)
ReplyDeleteAm I the only one who can't stand Jack? He's so... not Sawyer.
ReplyDeleteI feel like I've betrayed Mal by doing it, but I voted for Castiel.
I liked LOST but I recently got into Chuck and loved it, so my vote goes to Sarah Walker. And of course, Castiel, which I don't really need to explain, do I? :D
ReplyDeleteVote - Sarah and Castiel
ReplyDeleteSarah is of the best things about Chuck. She was campy and fun in the first 2 seasons. However, I am completely surprised that she is winning against Jack as he is usually so popular around here. I'm not a fan of LOST so I'm good if it stays this way although my bracket will have issues.
The match between Castiel and Mal is no issue for me. Castiel all the way. However, if this was a match between Cas and Rick Castle all bets would be off. Big fan of Nathan Fillion, not a big fan of Capt. Mal.
Voted for Sarah (couldn't get into Lost) and Malcolm - but have Jack and Castiel in my bracket...
ReplyDeleteCas vs Mal was the hardest match for me to predict because they largely pull from the same fanbase and both shows are hugely popular here. The reason I wavered so much is because I believe whoever takes this match will get to the Elite 8 unless Chuck stops them so picking wrong would break my bracket. In the end, I chose Castiel because there is a big section of Supernatural fans that are fighting to keep Cas on the show. This is a good way for them to show their Cas love. That being said, this is one of the major early rounds that could truly go either way.
ReplyDeleteSarah Walker and Malcolm Reynolds
ReplyDeleteMe too. I still think Jack will pull out a victory in the end though.
ReplyDeleteSame for me, Mal and Jack have both my heart.
ReplyDeleteJack and Castiel...i really like Sarah's character but against Jack it's a no-brainer...
ReplyDeleteNo I can't stand him either.
ReplyDeleteSarah and Mal for me here (sorry Cas I just love Mal more)
Damn you for pitting 4 of my favorite characters against each other. I have Jack and Mal in my brackets, which is definitely screwed now.
ReplyDeleteJack Shephard and Castiel.
ReplyDeleteMy vote is Jack Shepherd and Castiel.
ReplyDeleteI do too, but I also love the crazy things he would say. Especially he would get drunk in Season 5. Castiel is special.
ReplyDeleteI like Chuck, but I was and am a Lost fan: Jack Shepherd. I really don't understand all the whining about Firefly. It wasn't all that good. No wonder it got cancelled. I like Supernatural and Castiel is my favorite character, so that wasn't hard.
ReplyDeleteSarah and Cas!
ReplyDeleteThe Chuck fans are trying to kill my bracket... :(
ReplyDeletePeople is time to tell everyone you know to vote or more than half of the brackets are going down. F**ing chuck fans, no offense just worrying.
ReplyDeleteMore Mal :(
ReplyDeleteJack and Malcolm Great shows. Great characters.
ReplyDeleteHad to vote for the 'Giant Blond She-Male' Sarah Walker
ReplyDeleteand
Malcolm Reynolds
If Jack doesnt win today, my bracket is absolutely ruined.
ReplyDeleteVoted for Castiel and Jack. Think that putting Castiel as losing in the second round was a mistake though..
ReplyDeleteYou're not the only one. I love Sawyer, and didnt really like Jack at all. I voted for him though for my bracket.
ReplyDeleteHey Adam,
ReplyDeletethis one is not under Features - character cup competition. I've been looking there all day before I thought of checking the home page.
Oh whoops! :P I wrote the wrong label and so it hasn't listed there! It should be there now! Thanks for noticing and pointing it out! :)
ReplyDeleteFor Jack/Malcolms sakes then you need to have a lot of LOST firefly fans or there could be a shock on the cards :P
Big mistake :P
ReplyDeleteI expected Chuck himself to do okay, but I hadn't expected such support for Sarah.
ReplyDeletePlus M.Fox isn't exactly everyones favourite person atm :P
Haha... they are four big characters today!
ReplyDeleteThanks :)
ReplyDeleteI think a lot of brackets could weep tomorrow morning :P
ReplyDeleteI decided Chuck would stop Castiel... but in general I believe its Castiel or Chuck that will make the final 8...
ReplyDeleteeasy choices today
ReplyDeletevoted castiel and jack
castiel because he's an awesome character and jack because i love lost and haven't seen chuck
but i never really liked jack that much
right now both my predictions are wrong though :( but i am happy cas is winning
I didn't vote in the first one since I don't/didn't watch Chuck or Lost, but the second one had to be Mal for me. Love Supernatural, but Firefly... well, it's Firefly. How could I vote against Mal?
ReplyDeleteholy crap, we're beating Mal? That's highly impressive! Go Cas!fans! :D
ReplyDeleteCome one where's the Lost fans got to get Jack into the next round. It's very close right now.
ReplyDeleteAlso yeah for SPN fandom getting Cas so far ahead. ^_^
I'm an SPN fan and I put Cas losing in round three against Chuck. I just don't think there are enough Cas fans within SPN fandom to beat the power of the Chuck fandom for their main character.
ReplyDeleteI looked at the Chuck final season factor and debated a long time over this one too. Regardless, whoever makes it to the elite 8 will be stopped by the powerhouse that is Peter Bishop in my opinion. Only person who might be able stop him is Katherine Pierce.
ReplyDeleteThis one will go to the wire and may end up being which fan base is out of town for Labor day in the States. I think the strong support comes in the fact that it is Chuck's last season. Similar to how Clark Kent did very well last year but didn't even make it into the contest this year.
ReplyDeleteHa! I'd be pretty excited if so many of us were wrong so quickly in the contest. (I would be one of them.) It would give everyone a better chance at winning and make it a tighter race in my opinion. Plus it makes the whole contest more of a wild card. All equaling better entertainment before the fall shows premiere.
ReplyDeleteYou may be right. Chuck will be big competition, although I don't think there is as much Chuck-Supernatural fandom overlap anymore as there is Fringe-Supernatural. I still think Cas will prevail over Chuck but lose to Peter. However, this was a match that I wavered on more than most. Both fandoms are strong and they've gone against each other before. It will really be Chuck vs Supernatural - TV Guide cover part 4. I think it will be less about the characters.
ReplyDeleteI love Castiel, and Misha too, but I'm sorry, Capt. Mal is one sexy beast!
ReplyDeleteOMG it's currently a tie between Jack Shephard and Sarah Walker - both with 889 votes.
ReplyDeleteThis is going to be extremely close!
You think that Katherine can win over Peter?!Really?I don't know..I don't think so..
ReplyDeleteI think that until the final 8 the show which the characters are coming from will also play a very big role.So,I can see Castiel winning over Chuck.
After that the choices will be mostly based on the characters themselves.There are a lot people who love both Fringe and Supernatural.Peter has an advantage,that's for sure,but I don't think anything is certain.I was wondering if the season finale would affect the votes that Cas gets,but I don't think it has.He's close to 2000 votes(far more than Peter and Patrick combined)against a pretty tough opponent.Anything can happen!
It's gonna be so much fun!
still a tie at 915. Waaaaah!
ReplyDeletesarah and mal!
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion Castiel is the best character ever without doubt :-) Adorable, cute, innocent, helpful... he was like that at least. Love him!
ReplyDeleteSarah ♥ and Cas ;)
ReplyDeleteI'm not a Jack fan. However, I love Sawyer.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion Castiel is the best character ever :-) Adorable, cute, innocent, helpful... at least he was like that. And on top of that, he´s God now :D So it´s better to not piss he off :D Love him! (sorry for my English :-/)
ReplyDeleteThe fact that Mal is losing out to some no-neck from Supenatural is a crime of cosmic proportions.
ReplyDeleteI find it physically impossible to choose between Castiel and Malcom Reynolds. Damm you Misha and Nathan!
ReplyDeleteShut it Adam!
ReplyDeleteQuit rubbing it in our faces lol
Jack DID win last year, you know... :|
Thank god Jack won. I dont like him but my bracket would have been ruined if he'd lost. I still think my bracket will end up being ruined in round two though but at least it wont have been in round one :)
ReplyDeleteAnd I'm only sad Malcolm Reynolds lost just because I love Nathan Fillion..I've never seen firefly though so I did vote for Castiel for my bracket..
ReplyDelete"May have been the losing side. Still not convinced it was the wrong one." Not much to say.
ReplyDeleteNever thought Jack Shepherd could come close to being thrown out after round one. Good going Sarah!
ReplyDeleteI don't think that Katherine will win over Peter but if anyone in that region could, it would be Katherine. Looking at past polls, the Vampire Diaries crowd is hit or miss on SpoilerTV. Sometimes they come in with huge numbers and sometimes the show barely squeaks by. It will all depend on which one it is on that given day. (If both make it that far that is.)
ReplyDeleteI agree. There is no doubt to me that this contest reflects the show more often than it does the character. That might not be right, but most people will vote for their favorite shows regardless of what they think of that particular character. Generally that will change if it's a character someone particularly despises or when people have two shows they like against each other and then it comes down to character. Otherwise people tend to vote their show. That's why I think that if the Vampire Diaries is hot on the day the poll airs, Katherine COULD, but probably won't, beat Peter.
It is also possible that Castiel would beat Peter too for the same reason - he's on a very popular SPTV show. However, in the best show competition Fringe fans came out in spades. If the choice is a Supernatural character vs a Fringe character, I think we are guaranteed a repeat. It will be tougher to win though because both Peter and Castiel went through major changes at the end of the season. Since Castiel (and the angel storyline) is somewhat divisive and because many Supernatural fans are also fans of Fringe, I think Peter has an advantage in this match.
You're right though that anything could happen. It all depends on which fandoms awake and come out roaring in a particular 24 hours. I wonder how much summer being over and show premiere schedules will play a part in the results. I think it's a given that any show that premieres the day before one of its characters is in a round will cause a bounce in the voting.
If only winning polls would get them to let Cas to stay on the show!!
ReplyDeleteI was rallying votes late last night to try to squeak by a win for Jack in order to save my bracket. It obviously worked. ^_^
ReplyDeleteWow that was a close one with Jack and Diane sorrrry Sarah
ReplyDeleteJack is my LEAST fave Lostie. Whiny, whine, whinerson. But I usually vote for LOST on any poll.
ReplyDeleteTesting
ReplyDelete