So as you can tell from the ABC synopsis, the fairytale characters living in the town of Storybrooke have forgotten who they really are. They think that they're just ordinary people living in a curious little town, and they don't seem to notice that they're "frozen in time." So in a nutshell it's another "people trapped in a small weird town" show, not unlike The Prisoner and countless other shows. Except that Once Upon a Time is pretty fun never gets too dark or weird.
The good news is, Jennifer Morrison is totally engaging as Emma Swan, the bail bonds collector who may be the daughter of Snow White and Prince Charming. She has an early set piece that totally wins you over to her side, and you immediately start loving her resourcefulness and self-reliance. In fact, the cast is great in general — especially Big Love's Ginnifer Goodwin as Snow White, who totally sells you on some scenes that could look a bit silly otherwise. And Stargate Universe's Robert Carlyle looks like he'll be fascinatingly demented.
The conceit that these fairytale characters have forgotten who they really are means that Once Upon a Time finds a way to put fairytale characters in the real world without much incongruity. And long stretches of Once Upon a Time feel like they could come from any other TV show about cute schemers and lost souls in a vaguely suburban environment. And then you switch over to the events in Fairyland, which feels a bit like a Disney pastiche at times.
Source: Read the Full Review @ IO9
As long as this show stays fun and doesn't try to take itself too seriously I think I'll enjoy it.
ReplyDeletei kinda like the disney element adds a feel of whimsy :) lol
ReplyDeleteOoh, I'm really excited for this now! I didn't realize it was the same people trapped in what seems like an endless loop.
ReplyDeleteCan't wait for this!
Basically it is similar to the movie Enchanted!
ReplyDeleteShe highlighted my two major concerns for the series... sadly.
ReplyDeleteFirst is Fairyland too cartoon-like or childish? From her review I would guess yes.
Second is that change from real world to kidsville so distract that it doesn't flow and is just a cliche joke? Appears so.
Hopefully they find a way to make Fairyland a place that is still very realistic, but where fairytales happen to have originated. More like the Brothers Grimm and less like Disney.. more dark and violent than fluffy land fun. If they make Fairyland too much like a 10-year old's imagination it loses the most compelling aspect of the show for me - that both places are real and on a collision course.
If they lose the darkness and danger of the original folktales that spawned fairytales it loses anything that would make me watch.
The one big problem I will have with that show is the cartoon-like fairlyland. I'm really open to the show and everything, but I can see that scene with the bad CGI and awful costumes putting off so many people just because it looks so awful. If they really toned it down, toned down the costumes and just filmed it in a big room which was fancily done up I would be so much more excited for it, but now I'm meh.
ReplyDeleteDid you like the movie Enchanted? That is the type of animation they are devising!
ReplyDeleteAt least NBC's Grimm seems to be maintain darkness and danger
ReplyDeleteAs a male in his 20's I have no idea what that is and it is absolutely not sitting on my DVD shelf at this very moment.
ReplyDeleteI hope it's something I can watch with my 8 yr old ... there are very few shows that I can tolerate that I can let her watch with me ....
ReplyDeleteThe review didn't worry me. I can tell from the trailer that the Fairyland part of the show is closer in tone and appearance to a noir-ish Pushing Daisies taken to extremes as opposed to Enchanted, as has been suggested.
ReplyDeleteThis is one of those "just go with it" shows. I've found that If you can accept the show for what it is and still enjoy it, you're all set. If not, you'll just end up nitpicking it to death and it'll ruin the whole experience. If that's the case you're better off moving on.
ABC has the trailer in HD now:
http://www.youtube.com/user/ABCNetwork#p/search/0/BmWaOnpM_Ro
I am looking forward to Ginnifer Goodwin!
ReplyDeleteI am so excited, tht she has a new TV show so shortly after Big Love and despite her movies!
Once Upon A Time sounds interesting. Will it take Charlies Anals spot?
ReplyDelete